Bachelor 19 - Whitney Bischoff #2

GuardianAngel wrote:I don't think people have given up, for me anyway I'm just still sleuthing. There are a lot of good reasons why she is F1 but no solid proof as in something-gate or a s/cap.

ETA: exactly lurker. I don't look at it as trying to convince anyone of anything. It's the sleuthing that keeps it fun!

Yes!! This is what brought most of us here and so fun when we get a season like this one. ;)

umngirl wrote:^Which is exactly the point I was trying to make as there are some in the Becca thread using it as a clue to her being F1. I wanted to point out that it's happened with Whitney as well.

I did notice that last week. I don't know exactly where but I remember Whitney was wearing hot pink....maybe at the rose ceremony? I actually watched the episode twice and noticed it both times.

soccermom333 wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:I don't think people have given up, for me anyway I'm just still sleuthing. There are a lot of good reasons why she is F1 but no solid proof as in something-gate or a s/cap.

ETA: exactly lurker. I don't look at it as trying to convince anyone of anything. It's the sleuthing that keeps it fun!

Yes!!  This is what brought most of us here and so fun when we get a season like this one.  ;)

IA! I like to look at things from different perspectives.

umngirl wrote:^Which is exactly the point I was trying to make as there are some in the Becca thread using it as a clue to her being F1. I wanted to point out that it's happened with Whitney as well.

umn, to clarify, my point wasn't solely that "wife" was used over Becca as a clue that she was F1. My point was that every comment in that RC was true about the MOT girls (accept Britt). Each statement and the girl's edit was a perfect match. So, I was merely raising the possibility that what was said regarding both Becca and Whitney in that RC could be true as well. We won't know until until the FRC. As I said in my post, I found it fascinating...so I shared it. That is all.

Litta123 wrote:

umngirl wrote:^Which is exactly the point I was trying to make as there are some in the Becca thread using it as a clue to her being F1. I wanted to point out that it's happened with Whitney as well.

umn, to clarify, my point wasn't solely that "wife" was used over Becca as a clue that she was F1. My point was that every comment in that RC was true about the MOT girls (accept Britt). Each statement and the girl's edit was a perfect match. So, I was merely raising the possibility that what was said regarding both Becca and Whitney in that RC could be true as well. We won't know until until the FRC. As I said in my post, I found it fascinating...so I shared it. That is all.

I got what you were referring to Litta. I didn't see you post the occurrences of it for Whitney or really reference them (I may have missed them) so I wanted to bring it up in the Whitney thread that it as happened for her as well so it's not really an "Easter egg" as JBF would say.

A word of caution, if I see any more posts questioning what sleuthers are doing, and why, they will be deleted.

This is a sleuthing forum. If you don't agree with the hard work being done by sleuthers, then I suggest other forms of enjoyment, in the Fan thread or other threads on this forum.

I would like to make it clear, there are plenty of sleuthers who don't care who the spoiled F1 is. Their agenda is to sleuth, and not prove anyone right or wrong.  

TY

Diana wrote:Yeah that is true. imo Becca didn't seem as invested as Whitney though. :hidingchair so it could be easier for her to do so. I just don't see Whitney doing it. But that could be wrong. I guess we will know in two weeks.

Diana wrote:

Idlemess wrote:

sanlee088 wrote:Whitney was so into Chris, that I also find it hard to believe that she would be posting pics of her and Chris and following him, etc. if she wasn't the F1. I guess though it's possible she would. We just don't really know. And yep, two weeks to go!

Confident women don't hate .... she says

She is carryon on with her life and fulfilling obligation for the show

So could Becca though. It goes both ways in both scenarios

sanlee088 wrote:

mindless wrote:Whitney doesn't really strike me as someone who would wallow in heartbreak. She's gone through way worse stuff in her life than not being chosen by a guy she's known for 5 minutes and bounced back. I think she's got enough perspective on things to get over Chris quite soon, if it came to that.

Good point! She does seem mature enough to realize hey, he didn't choose me. I need to get over it. I was probably wrong about her. Maybe she is/will/did bounce back quickly if she isn't the F1.

umngirl wrote:My hope that if Whit isn't F1 that she already has someone special in her life and odds would say that that relationship would probably last longer than than Chris with his F1 anyway. I like her more than Chris so I'd rather see her happy than him, but if she is with him I will wish them happiness.

I think that both Becca and Whitney have shown a lot of maturity and for the most part stayed out of the fray of this season, though Becca a little more IMO. Both are great women and Chris would be lucky to have either. I also think they are both really happy. I have enjoyed watching the interaction grow with Becca and I finally saw on episode 7 and 8 that Chris was as into Whitney as she was into him. So really either way would be great. I think it just comes down to does Chris really wants. I don't think that either necessarily make him better than the other, but he is more of a follower with Whitney and more leader with Becca. At the end, either one could be great for him and he would be extremely lucky to end up with either woman.

nuts2uiam wrote:Another reason to me that Whitney is the F1 is that she obviously has had a few relationships in the past.  If I were a guy, Becca's virginity would not concern me, rather a virgin, than a Jade, (sorry to be so harsh, just having a hard time thinking about the holiday conversations with the family, especially the guys).  But what would have me concerned is that if I am her first boyfriend she may really not know what she wants in a long term partner.  That would scare the hell out of me.  That is not to say it couldn't work, as I have plenty of friends still married to HS sweethearts, just thinking about it pertaining to this scenario.

I will just say that in my life, most men I have met are more than happy to be the love of someone's life and plenty are excited to be the first love of a woman's life. Hasn't when you know you, been the saying lately?

Diana wrote:Per RS

Nothing that happened since Nov 22nd means anything. There are no arguments to be made when the outcome has already been determined. If he was still deciding between the two, then sure. But he decided 3 months ago so anything on social media since then means nothing. Producers purposely tell contestants to say/do things on Twitter every season.

Keep the faith guys!

I do agree, nothing that happens between now and the finale will change anything that happened on Nov 22nd. Great that they could find a great edit to make a great story for two girls.

sanlee088 wrote:

Jeepers wrote:Back on the Whitney train .. Re watching their 1st 1n1 .. Both of their reactions when he gave her rose .. He was definitely hooked

That WAS the cutest thing ever. He looked like a little boy so giddy. :cutesmile!:

relaxing wrote:I still think it will be Whitney. And I think she's the right choice for him at this stage.   But they've hooked me with the Becca Chris story the last few eps and I have no doubt he has strong and growing feelings for her, too.  I think he'll  truly wrestle with his decision at the end.  

I don't think it was first date with Whitney and done for Chris.  But I think he did start to fall hard that night and was excited to find a real viable potential for himself.   I loved Chris reaction at the end of Whitney's date, no denying he was a giddy little boy with a major crush giving her the rose.  No doubt he has an energy and glow about him with Whitney.  But also I do see Chris reacting with tenderness, patience and passion towards the slower moving Becca. I can't help but think about how long ago that giddy reaction was, and that sometimes a slow moving, genuine connection comes along to beat out that initial perfect first date.

What does in love Chris look like - the giddly grinning giggly guy or the manly, protective wooing Chris? Probably a bit of both, that's why I think I totally buy both relationships.  So I could easily believe either as F1, and would find either ending quite a romantic, emotional one and would be a fan of either couple.  Can he pick both? J/K

The only thing that makes me hesitate about the wonderfulness of the first date is Brooks and Des. They had the best first date ever. It was sweet, cute and adorable. Same with Chris and Whitney. But that is one date. Overtime Chris S grew in his love for Des and she grew to appreciate him. Whereas Brooks and Des didn't really grow past that first amazing date.

I think Chris and Whitney have grown, but since they started so high they didn't have far to go. Sometimes the slow growing passion can seem stronger than that spark that may stutter later.

I don't care who he picks, but they are both great relationships.

At the end of this season, Chris was so lucky to have three really wonderful woman. He truly can't make a bad pick to me from any of his F3. We saw the F3 last night, so we know the F2 and really he can't go wrong with either of them. Most importantly both Whitney and Becca are really happy, so I care less on who he picks, since he is extremely lucky and each of the girls is good, so congrats to all of them on an awesome season the happiness that all three have now.

Becca's hanging out with Kaitlyn today. So any ideas what Whitney is up to?

So, I'm new at this posting stuff, so please forgive me up front. Someone asked yesterday where in KY Whitney lived. She was born and raised in Louisville. After High School graduation, she moved to Lexington to attend UK. After graduation she moved to Charleston, SC for one year, then to Chicago, where her sister Kimberly lived. Her sister has since moved to NC.

Not A Fan wrote:So, I'm new at this posting stuff, so please forgive me up front. Someone asked yesterday where in KY Whitney lived. She was born and raised in Louisville. After High School graduation, she moved to Lexington to attend UK. After graduation she moved to Charleston, SC for one year, then to Chicago, where her sister Kimberly lived. Her sister has since moved to NC.

Not A Fan! Thanks for all the info on Whitney!

In the DR with her girls  

Diana wrote:Becca's hanging out with Kaitlyn today. So any ideas what Whitney is up to?

She posted on IG that she was headed to the beach with the girls around Feb 19th with the hashtag #DR. So it is assumed she went to the Dominican Republic.