Bachelor 19 - Whitney Bischoff #2

umngirl wrote:Man there are some ugly looking dresses in those F3 RC line-ups.

My thoughts exactly. What the hell are they wearing?

To be fair on Whitney Cat also said she wouldn't have done the show if Sean wasn't The Bachelor , same for JP I think(Can't remember properly). I don't think she went there certain she was gonna be picked as the F1. The are 30 women that were in the show so the odds were against her. She might have liked some attributes she saw on Chris and thought...hmmmm I like this guy, let me try out. It isn't that weird.

I agree with Whitney having an interest being on the show possibly knowing that it was Chris.

Which leads me to think about Chris' reasons for having her in his F2. Whitney it seems from day 1 kept her focus on developing and maintaining a relationship with Chris never wavering, it appears. She TELLS him literally what she wants and feels so far...

My question as others have asked: WHY take someone to that point to break their heart?
With Chris knowing so far that Whitney appears vested and is into him big time...why take her there?
(I know someone has to be there, hearts (in that moment) will be broken, but seriously if there is still no doubt why go there

truelovealways wrote:...And, the girls standing where Whit is standing have all been F2/F3

Back in the days before spoilers weren't some of the screencaps flipped so we didn't know who was originally standing on the left or the right

Idlemess wrote:... With Chris knowing so far that Whitney appears vested and is into him big time...why take her there?  

IMO Chris chose Whitney as his F1 because she was the one he could see a future with. The big for me is will they last long term

Eviebloom wrote:My suspicious mind wonders if about the 6th episode, someone from the bachelor brass, posts opposing opinions on here, just to mess with the press and the fans.   Maybe I am giving too much credit to this board.  But once the show is in full swing, and the F1 seems to be established.... There are posters that keep the questions coming, even though the opinions are  stretching to find connections?  However, I come here to see the sleuthing that you all do.  I think this happened with the Des and Brooks connection.  Maybe I am just suspicious.  That seems to be happening with this season, between Whitney and Becca.  Anyone else wonder about this?

Please feel free to give as much credit to the board as you would like because they deserve it. There are posters here who spend an awful long time and many hours, sleuthing every possible detail there is in order to sleuth the season. Regardless of what the spoilers are, there is never a good reason to stop sleuthing. There was a time when there weren't any spoilers, and the sleuthers did just fine without them.

I hope there will never be a lack of posters who question the F1 nor posters who stretch to find connections. All these actions make us better sleuthers.

So regardless of who posts, we welcome all opinions, and we never question who they are, or what their opinions are. We discuss, comment and sleuth all contestants but we never question what others are thinking, or doing. We all have our right to sleuth what when where and how we want, and post opinions along the way.

jen689 wrote:

truelovealways wrote:...And, the girls standing where Whit is standing have all been F2/F3

Back in the days before spoilers weren't some of the screencaps flipped so we didn't know who was originally standing on the left or the right

And who stood where on Meet and Greet Night 1 and if it was as easy to guess based on F3 line up then it a huge giveaway for all seasons

Diana wrote:I often wonder what RS has that he's so sure it's Whitney. If she turns out to be F1, I wonder if RS will share.

He does not share his sources. I don't blame him. That is the fastest way to lose a source.

Kashathediva wrote:

Diana wrote:I often wonder what RS has that he's so sure it's Whitney. If she turns out to be F1, I wonder if RS will share.

He does not share his sources. I don't blame him. That is the fastest way to lose a source.

I know all about that! I wouldn't reveal them either. Just wondering.

Diana wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:

Diana wrote:I often wonder what RS has that he's so sure it's Whitney. If she turns out to be F1, I wonder if RS will share.

He does not share his sources. I don't blame him. That is the fastest way to lose a source.

I know all about that! I wouldn't reveal them either. Just wondering.

According to him, he said that he got information out of Dubuque, either the evening of, or the day after the FRC, I can't remember.

RS has lost that 'get married' bet several times now .. And had to send a wedding present as part of the deal LOL

julychild wrote:

Diana wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:
He does not share his sources. I don't blame him. That is the fastest way to lose a source.

I know all about that! I wouldn't reveal them either. Just wondering.

According to him, he said that he got information out of Dubuque, either the evening of, or the day after the FRC, I can't remember.

I thought the FRC took place at his farm? How would anyone in Dubuque know what went on?

Diana wrote:

Mommyof1 wrote:

truelovealways wrote:Interesting so Cat and Emily both F1's are in the same position as Becca (middle)

And Molly (who was the true F1).  

I wouldn't count Molly. Melissa was the F1 no matter how it turned out.

Yeah, I agree - Jason has said that he had decided on Melissa by the time of the FS dates, so as far as TPTB knew, Melissa was the F1.