Re: Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray - Fan Forum - General Discussion Thread #3

[AnandaMarie]

Sorry but I disagree with everyone who thinks that Josh should be the bachelor. I still feel that he and Andi were perfect together and I hope they get back together.

[edenpol]

Sorry but I disagree with everyone who thinks that Josh should be the bachelor. I still feel that he and Andi were perfect together and I hope they get back together.

Amen!! I won't stop wanting this, even if for some it seems too unreal.

[Kashathediva]

Josh does not look happy in that picture.

He looks totally dishevelled.

[Linds911]

Here's the other pic from the photoshoot that Josh posted on Twitter (which is still there) back in November.

[sara11]

I truly want Josh to be happy and I don't think that being the bachelor is the way to do this, the track record is terrible (only Sean and Jason have made it work!) and it would just push his plans to marry and have kids further back. And quite frankly I don't want to see him say the same things he did to Andi, to someone else - I wouldn't be able to buy into it.

[AnandaMarie]

I truly want Josh to be happy and I don't think that being the bachelor is the way to do this, the track record is terrible (only Sean and Jason have made it work!) and it would just push his plans to marry and have kids further back. And quite frankly I don't want to see him say the same things he did to Andi, to someone else - I wouldn't be able to buy into it.

Yeah I can't see him say those things to anybody else. That's part of why I would love to see him and Andi get back together.

[mtnlvr55]

Here's the other pic from the photoshoot that Josh posted on Twitter (which is still there) back in November.

When I saw this picture and now seeing the new picture, I thought that it did not look like a couple in love. They are beautiful, they look amazing but they don't look "connected." I think Josh's comment was telling as well--he talked about the location but not about the person he was with. At the time I dismissed it but looking back, I think that at this point there was some kind of disconnect for the two of them.

[aviej]

I think they look lovely in that photo. Josh has serious face poses, it doesn't necessarily mean he's unhappy. Anyways, I DON'T want him to be the next Bachelor and if we honestly want him to find a wife and have the best chance of lasting love we won't want that for him either....unless he lives on a farm in Iowa and has trouble meeting girls! Anyways the only way I would condone him returning to the bachelor is if Andi is there to vie for his heart again and they end up together. But seriously, I don't wish it for him at all. Fame and fortune in this franchise has done more to damage people's reputation than enhance it, IMO. I wish that they are bombarded with pics and memories of the better times and that they really start to think when did things go wrong. Josh and Andi got to knwo each other much faster than most couples in the franchise so while they lasted 8 mths it would have been well over a year if they didn't live in the same state and saw each other every other week-end. I think by August/September Josh would have known already the kind of woman she was etc. And he would not have dragged it on a minute further if he knew things couldn't work out. But I believe, as the events got more frequent and the money earning opportunities increased, things took a turn for the worse. I think minus those things, we'd have our happy couple. Andi said she knows what kind of values he has and she trusts their love and relationship.

[Maggenzm]

But, we have to understand that, they have grown as individual through meeting each other and working out their relationship, so the next person they meet, they will be more closer to understanding what they really want and need in the person they want to marry.

I think, it's Josh who broke off the engagement, bcs he already changed his twitter account picture, while Andi still has the engagement picture on hers. So, I think she is still hoping for a reconciliation. If that's the case, then it ai'nt over yet. Because as long as one of them wants it, there is a big possibility that they might get back together.

[AnandaMarie]

I think they look lovely in that photo. Josh has serious face poses, it doesn't necessarily mean he's unhappy. Anyways, I DON'T want him to be the next Bachelor and if we honestly want him to find a wife and have the best chance of lasting love we won't want that for him either....unless he lives on a farm in Iowa and has trouble meeting girls! Anyways the only way I would condone him returning to the bachelor is if Andi is there to vie for his heart again and they end up together. But seriously, I don't wish it for him at all. Fame and fortune in this franchise has done more to damage people's reputation than enhance it, IMO. I wish that they are bombarded with pics and memories of the better times and that they really start to think when did things go wrong. Josh and Andi got to knwo each other much faster than most couples in the franchise so while they lasted 8 mths it would have been well over a year if they didn't live in the same state and saw each other every other week-end. I think by August/September Josh would have known already the kind of woman she was etc. And he would not have dragged it on a minute further if he knew things couldn't work out. But I believe, as the events got more frequent and the money earning opportunities increased, things took a turn for the worse. I think minus those things, we'd have our happy couple. Andi said she knows what kind of values he has and she trusts their love and relationship.

Yes aviej, I completely agree. You made my day with this post. I don't know if josh looked unhappy because you're right, he does have serious face poses. I would also hate to see him be the Bachelor unless Andi is there to vie for his heart because I can't see him with anybody other than Andi. Aviej, I think the last part of your post is the best and most correct. They lived together for 8 months and I think that by September he knew exactly who Andi was and knew that she was the person that he wanted to be with. I don't think that 8 months later he was now learning things he didn't like. I agree when you said that the travelling and opportunities increased and took a toll in their relationship. That's why I would like to see them get back together and make it work without the opportunities and being in the public eye.

[AnandaMarie]

And aviej, I do hope as well that they are bombarded with pictures and memories which will make them reconsider their decision and hopefully will bring them back together.

[soccermom333]

latravelmagazine
2 hours ago
Sending some love and positive vibes today to one of our favorite couples as they go their separate ways. We were saddened to hear the news of their decision to call off their engagement as they both are such amazing people. This picture from our recent photoshoot @rclagunaniguel with them really shows just how beautiful they are inside and out. 
We wish you all the best @andi_dorfman@joshmurray11 and loved getting to know you on a personal level! Xoxo

Thanks Sara! Wow, they are stunning and HOT together. The timing is awful but..... look at the positive... what a way to end on a high note. Beautiful picture. They do look like models.

[Sponsored content]