Bachelor Canada Season 2 - Screen Caps - Pics - *Sleuthing* - *Spoilers* - Discussion #2

4health wrote:

sophienette wrote:I can see that makes sense...

Some unrelated thoughts:

- if he fell really hard a long time ago for Trish, significantly enough, ...how come he both ran after April to consol/frolick with her on beach and kiss Kaylynn at the GD in front of her?

I dont think we have seen anything about April seeing him kiss other girls?

Seems two things that are pretty rough if she is F1..


On the flipside, I am still seeing how Trish could be F1... any toughts on my earlier post?

exactly when he fell we don't know....as for the ocean consol/frolick they all witness it and that was before Trisha's 2:1 private island date and the kissing Kaylynn at wonderland date was Tim's worst date and knew he was in trouble with a few (three of his F4)  April was involved in the shark date where she comments about the kissing Dom and then kisses Kaylynn within seconds of each other.  So I think any F1 will have rough times.  JMO

Yes but my main note is that he didnt do the kissing in front of April... And April was not in the convo after Kaylynn went back to the group on that date, she was busy on the swing. They all know he would kiss others... but she didnt have to witness it.

tigertiz wrote:But he said he fell for her a "long" time ago. To me , that refers back to some time before the hometown week. I just dont see it as having anything to do with hometown week. YMMV.  
I'd appreciate seeing the producer's quote that refers to controlling the social media of the Lead (post filming.)  Especially in light of the favoriting of yet another tweet that sophienette found from Tara Dawn.  To me it seems that he is free to favorite whatever he  wishes to , on his personal twitter. (within reason)  And what he's favoriting is April.   It's just one more piece of evidence though, in a huge list.  Thanks so much sophienette, for bringing it to our attention!   I love the sleuthing here!  

sophienette wrote:

chrissy1295 wrote:He also favourited this tweet. He could be trying to mislead viewers, or he doesn't care about basically spoiling the ending.

and this... nothing about any of the other girls...

So glad April got another rose on [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] from [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] ! [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

— Tara-Dawn (@TaraDawnOnChay) [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

But my thought on that is....after having all the hometowns and knowing how they went, why would he say something like that if he didn't have those really strong feelings for Trisha? Why hurt her if he's feeling more for someone else like April for example. To me, that statement that was made at the very last hometown date actually means more than any other statement made throughout the dates before the last one. Hope I am explaining my thoughts well here.

I know that it is thought that he's a gonner for April, but if that's the case, why tell Trisha what he did on the very last hometown date??

sophienette wrote:

4health wrote:

sophienette wrote:I can see that makes sense...

Some unrelated thoughts:

- if he fell really hard a long time ago for Trish, significantly enough, ...how come he both ran after April to consol/frolick with her on beach and kiss Kaylynn at the GD in front of her?

I dont think we have seen anything about April seeing him kiss other girls?

Seems two things that are pretty rough if she is F1..


On the flipside, I am still seeing how Trish could be F1... any toughts on my earlier post?

exactly when he fell we don't know....as for the ocean consol/frolick they all witness it and that was before Trisha's 2:1 private island date and the kissing Kaylynn at wonderland date was Tim's worst date and knew he was in trouble with a few (three of his F4)  April was involved in the shark date where she comments about the kissing Dom and then kisses Kaylynn within seconds of each other.  So I think any F1 will have rough times.  JMO

Yes but my main note is that he didnt do the kissing in front of April... And April was not in the convo after Kaylynn went back to the group on that date, she was busy on the swing. They all know he would kiss others... but she didnt have to witness it.

Yes she didn't have to witness it but April was there when Dom tells the girls that she just kissed Tim it was Kaylynn that was with Tim. April didn't know that he just kissed Kaylynn also. So, she was surprise at how quickly like 10 minutes when Dom and Tim kissed. My point is that both F2 girls had to experience uncomfortable situations. I guess I don't understand what Tim declares to Trisha has less weight just because she witness kissing in front her and April didn't....called me confused

I've noticed in that passionate kiss with april that didn't make it into the episodes, his hand is grabbing the back of her head as to pull her in. i noticed he does that with trish too, but its very loosely grabbing her head even though their kisses are more passionate. but remember how josh and andi said those small kisses are more intimate than the makeouts, and so far we've seen those little small kisses between tim and april.

joshfan wrote:I've noticed in that passionate kiss with april that didn't make it into the episodes, his hand is grabbing the back of her head as to pull her in. i noticed he does that with trish too, but its very loosely grabbing her head even though their kisses are more passionate. but remember how josh and andi said those small kisses are more intimate than the makeouts, and so far we've seen those little small kisses between tim and april.

It all depends on the people kissing right?  I guess my confusion is how do you know from a SC that Tim and April's kiss was so steamy or passionate....I mean if you go and watch the kiss that did make it to the episode (hello kiss) his mouth didn't pucker or even slightly open at all.    pretty boring to me   I like a little more heat in my kisses. But hey to each their own, we will know soon enough right.

4health wrote:

joshfan wrote:I've noticed in that passionate kiss with april that didn't make it into the episodes, his hand is grabbing the back of her head as to pull her in. i noticed he does that with trish too, but its very loosely grabbing her head even though their kisses are more passionate. but remember how josh and andi said those small kisses are more intimate than the makeouts, and so far we've seen those little small kisses between tim and april.

It all depends on the people kissing right?  I guess my confusion is how do you know from a SC that Tim and April's kiss was so steamy or passionate....I mean if you go and watch the kiss that did make it to the episode (hello kiss) his mouth didn't pucker or even slightly open at all.    pretty boring to me   I like a little more heat in my kisses.  But hey to each their own, we will know soon enough right.

i guess so HAHA ! just really wondering what april could be crying about hmm. it's so close to the end, it would be so stupid if it was the competition cause its 50/50 at that point. really wondering what it could be

Auntie - I am trying to figure out when those strong feelings started... as for telling her... well every leads has told their f2, and some more than that, that they had feelings for them...


again, I am not saying he didnt mean what he said! Just that he may not have meant it in the way we think... you know the classic "I love you but I love someone else more"...

or maybe he did and all the April F1 clues some of us are seeing are just wrong or fake... but I would like to be able to discuss all views and arguments for both fairly.

I am not dismissing the importance of what we see him say to Trish. I m trying to contextualize it, as you did as well with your timeline, which I think was great. Only our interpretation of the impact of it differs

What I am questioning is why most of the pro-April clues and info are not being mentioned and discssed by pro-Trish?

I want to discuss them all! It it past 2 AM here so I aint going there now , but I would love to see a list of clues for both sides, like was done for Josh and Nick. ( Any volunteer?

4health wrote:

joshfan wrote:I've noticed in that passionate kiss with april that didn't make it into the episodes, his hand is grabbing the back of her head as to pull her in. i noticed he does that with trish too, but its very loosely grabbing her head even though their kisses are more passionate. but remember how josh and andi said those small kisses are more intimate than the makeouts, and so far we've seen those little small kisses between tim and april.

It all depends on the people kissing right?  I guess my confusion is how do you know from a SC that Tim and April's kiss was so steamy or passionate....I mean if you go and watch the kiss that did make it to the episode (hello kiss) his mouth didn't pucker or even slightly open at all.    pretty boring to me   I like a little more heat in my kisses.  But hey to each their own, we will know soon enough right.

.... there was no Hello kiss for Trish BTW, until after she gave him the jersey.

Hello guys.
I have a question. Even if Trisha's date was last, how can we be sure he didn't proclaim love to his other F2?
Remember we didnt get to see everything said during his goodbye to april.
He could have tell her the exact same thing for all we know, hence him feeling at ease for telling Trish too.
All i know is that Tim seems to like both girls very much.
So if we are comparing off sreen stuff (hometown dates real order) to what have been shown us (actual dates), lets remember we have not been shown everything.

sophienette wrote:

4health wrote:

joshfan wrote:I've noticed in that passionate kiss with april that didn't make it into the episodes, his hand is grabbing the back of her head as to pull her in. i noticed he does that with trish too, but its very loosely grabbing her head even though their kisses are more passionate. but remember how josh and andi said those small kisses are more intimate than the makeouts, and so far we've seen those little small kisses between tim and april.

It all depends on the people kissing right?  I guess my confusion is how do you know from a SC that Tim and April's kiss was so steamy or passionate....I mean if you go and watch the kiss that did make it to the episode (hello kiss) his mouth didn't pucker or even slightly open at all.    pretty boring to me   I like a little more heat in my kisses.  But hey to each their own, we will know soon enough right.

.... there was no Hello kiss for Trish BTW, until after she gave him the jersey.

yes but I think they were so excited the I think she almost gets knocked over and she laughs and is so excited to give her present that the hello hug came first......if you watch the kiss that did come after the jersey you hear him moan and then she does.

sophienette wrote:Auntie - I am trying to figure out when those strong feelings started... as for telling her... well every leads has told their f2, and some more than that, that they had feelings for them...


again, I am not saying he didnt mean what he said! Just that he may not have meant it in the way we think... you know the classic "I love you but I love someone else more"...

or maybe he did and all the April F1 clues some of us are seeing are just wrong or fake... but I would like to be able to discuss all views and arguments for both fairly.

I am not dismissing the importance of what we see him say to Trish. I m trying to contextualize it, as you did as well with your timeline, which I think was great. Only our interpretation of the impact of it differs

What I am questioning is why most of the pro-April clues and info are not being mentioned and discssed by pro-Trish?

I want to discuss them all! It it past 2 AM here so I aint going there now , but I would love to see a list of clues for both sides, like was done for Josh and Nick. ( Any volunteer?

I totally agree that Tim wasn't saying "I love you" when he said that he'd fallen for her a long time ago. She had just said "I'm falling for you"... and I think he just meant to say that he'd started falling for her a long time ago... in that, he really liked her from the start. I think that's the only reason that production left it in, because he misspoke and it worked well for them to confuse people who think April is F1.

sophienette wrote:I can see that makes sense...

Some unrelated thoughts:

- if he fell really hard a long time ago for Trish, significantly enough, ...how come he both ran after April to consol/frolick with her on beach and kiss Kaylynn at the GD in front of her?

I dont think we have seen anything about April seeing him kiss other girls?

Seems two things that are pretty rough if she is F1..


On the flipside, I am still seeing how Trish could be F1,... any toughts on my earlier post in the Speculation thread (about my spinning head)?

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

with that post, in a round abouts way wondering if he actually chose anyone?

IMO, we are missing a chunk of the affection/serious stuff. I understand we are getting that with April, but IMO, he's really having to work at it and to be honest, I don't know if he feels the work is worth it in the long run.

When you look at what is said face to face with April and Trish on each of their HTD's, to me, yes, April opened up more to him, but as he stated....In that moment, he was falling hard for her. If they are together, why leave that in there? IMO, that leaves the door open for Trish to be the F1. Then with his comment to Trish on HTD, to me that makes it even more significant.

Hope I am making sense?