Re: Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray - Fan Forum - Facebook - Twitter - IG's - Updates - Discussion Thread #2

[aviej]

I agree with you bamagal. This is the best love story even with Andi trying to hide her feelings for Josh. Her feelings still came thru with her famous words "Is this too good to be true". Glald to see how much Josh fell in love with her. I wish they would make a DVD of all the JODI scenes.

I agree with what you guys said. The most disappointing part for me was in the DR when Josh said on the bench with Andi that he loves her. It was clear that she had heard him say it before - perhaps on the HTD. And I'm really disappointed that TPTB robbed us of that precious moment, given how enamored she looked when he told her I'm falling in love with you.

Actually he said in the interview today that he hadn't said he loved you yet by the time of Nicks' fantasy date and that's why he knew she had to go through the whole process, when they brought up the whole Nick comment. He said he told her on his fantasy date that he was in love with her and through that whole time she was still nervous that he was going to leave. The interview today made me feel much better about the whole Nick situation. Josh totally got it, and now I do too.  

What a great interview this was, the best yet! they asked great questions. I loved when Josh got all worked about when the interviewer asked him about the dirty player who was taking late hits on Aaron. He said he could see Josh getting all worked up. Josh said i don't care if he's got 100 pounds on me! And then when talking about Nick and Josh said he was backstage in seclusion, Andi says something to the affect of , so he didn't bash his skull in.

I think the announcement in a couple of weeks is that they're both doing dancing with the stars. they're not going to announce a wedding date so early, unless they're doing a show leading up to it and that's what they are going to announce. The timing of "a couple of weeks" seems to fit with Sept 4th's DWTS cast announcement.

Interesting post. I guess I have to listen to the interview to really grasp things better. It does put things into perspective though that he hadn't said I love you up to Nick's post. Explains why, out of frustration she just gave into Nick. Had he told her upfront - Nick probably might not have even gotten an option to go into the fantasy suite! Concerning DWTS, who knows, maybe they'd learn some steps for their wedding dance! I guess competing against each other too would also make them want and love each other more - add some more spice (not that they need it) to the relationship.

[Trueloveforever]

I agree with you bamagal. This is the best love story even with Andi trying to hide her feelings for Josh. Her feelings still came thru with her famous words "Is this too good to be true". Glald to see how much Josh fell in love with her. I wish they would make a DVD of all the JODI scenes.

I agree with what you guys said. The most disappointing part for me was in the DR when Josh said on the bench with Andi that he loves her. It was clear that she had heard him say it before - perhaps on the HTD. And I'm really disappointed that TPTB robbed us of that precious moment, given how enamored she looked when he told her I'm falling in love with you.

Actually he said in the interview today that he hadn't said he loved you yet by the time of Nicks' fantasy date and that's why he knew she had to go through the whole process, when they brought up the whole Nick comment. He said he told her on his fantasy date that he was in love with her and through that whole time she was still nervous that he was going to leave. The interview today made me feel much better about the whole Nick situation. Josh totally got it, and now I do too.  

What a great interview this was, the best yet! they asked great questions. I loved when Josh got all worked about when the interviewer asked him about the dirty player who was taking late hits on Aaron. He said he could see Josh getting all worked up. Josh said i don't care if he's got 100 pounds on me! And then when talking about Nick and Josh said he was backstage in seclusion, Andi says something to the affect of , so he didn't bash his skull in.

I think the announcement in a couple of weeks is that they're both doing dancing with the stars. they're not going to announce a wedding date so early, unless they're doing a show leading up to it and that's what they are going to announce. The timing of "a couple of weeks" seems to fit with Sept 4th's DWTS cast announcement.

It does fit, however Josh did say they both love ATL and don't plan on moving to LA at all, and in order to do DWTS they're gonna need to move there. Plus he's still with capstone too, he mentioned he loved helping people so it seems like he's still working as well. I think they might just announce they're gonna have their wedding on TV, or just a date.

[Alanna]

I don't think they're doing dwts but we'll see. I love that Andi said they needed to keep josh away from Nick for safety reasons  Josh has handled this all way better than I ever gave him credit for when we spec'd on Andi/Nick fs before the atfr started but like, I mean, it's still Josh! Ha. I hope they put the interview up soon!!

[Guest]

After watching available videos from this season, I realize more and more that the "edits" really painted Josh in a bad light!  Is it just me, or is it upsetting to you that TPTB left a lot of the developing relationship "on the cutting room floor"?  I am convinced that once they saw how popular Josh was with the viewing audience, they had him pegged for the next Bachelor. What a shame to rob of us of watching the best love story EVER to come out of this franchise!

I agree with you bamagal. This is the best love story even with Andi trying to hide her feelings for Josh. Her feelings still came thru with her famous words "Is this too good to be true". Glald to see how much Josh fell in love with her. I wish they would make a DVD of all the JODI scenes.

I agree with what you guys said. The most disappointing part for me was in the DR when Josh said on the bench with Andi that he loves her. It was clear that she had heard him say it before - perhaps on the HTD. And I'm really disappointed that TPTB robbed us of that precious moment, given how enamored she looked when he told her I'm falling in love with you.

After the interview today, I'm convinced he did not say ILY during HTD. He said today she actually thought he was going to leave. I guess even after HTD she was still scared and convinced herself Josh was going to pull a Brooks on her.

I do agree on the bench was not the first time he said it...she did not look surprised. So may be he said it earlier during the date. The moment he saw her (if he couldn't wait to get it off his chest) and maybe and producers had him tell her again on the bench...just a theory.

[1funnyfish]

It's not DWTS. They said they are not moving to LA and are planning on staying in ATL. To do DWTS, everyone has to temporarily move out there like Sean and Catherine did. And the "announcement" was in response to a comment about their wedding.

This is so exciting!!!

[Relalou]

I agree with you bamagal. This is the best love story even with Andi trying to hide her feelings for Josh. Her feelings still came thru with her famous words "Is this too good to be true". Glald to see how much Josh fell in love with her. I wish they would make a DVD of all the JODI scenes.

I agree with what you guys said. The most disappointing part for me was in the DR when Josh said on the bench with Andi that he loves her. It was clear that she had heard him say it before - perhaps on the HTD. And I'm really disappointed that TPTB robbed us of that precious moment, given how enamored she looked when he told her I'm falling in love with you.

After the interview today, I'm convinced he did not say ILY during HTD.   He said today she actually thought he was going to leave.    I guess even after HTD  she was  still scared and convinced herself Josh was going to pull a Brooks on her.

I do agree on the bench was not the first time he said it...she did not look surprised.  So may be he said it earlier during the date.  The moment he saw her (if he couldn't wait to get it off his chest) and  maybe and producers had him tell her again on the bench...just a theory.  

My theory is that it was on the bench he said ILY for the first time, but TPTB spliced and diced it up to mitigate Andi's first response to it. Josh says ILY several times on that bench and the first time they show it, it does seem that Andi already knows. However a little later when he says it (in a fairly jumpy edited sequence) you can see her eyes are teary and she is far more emotional. The sneaky edit just served to hide Andi's joy IMO. Josh has said several times that they didn't have filters and so a lot couldn't be shown. I think this might be one such instance. Again IMO.

[1funnyfish]

Thinking the announcement could be made on a possible BIP finale (cast tells all)?! A few weeks ago RS said that they haven't ruled out a finale for that show yet.

[Trueloveforever]

It's not DWTS. They said they are not moving to LA and are planning on staying in ATL. To do DWTS, everyone has to temporarily move out there like Sean and Catherine did. And the "announcement" was in response to a comment about their wedding.

This is so exciting!!!

  

[Guest]

I agree with what you guys said. The most disappointing part for me was in the DR when Josh said on the bench with Andi that he loves her. It was clear that she had heard him say it before - perhaps on the HTD. And I'm really disappointed that TPTB robbed us of that precious moment, given how enamored she looked when he told her I'm falling in love with you.

Actually he said in the interview today that he hadn't said he loved you yet by the time of Nicks' fantasy date and that's why he knew she had to go through the whole process, when they brought up the whole Nick comment. He said he told her on his fantasy date that he was in love with her and through that whole time she was still nervous that he was going to leave. The interview today made me feel much better about the whole Nick situation. Josh totally got it, and now I do too.  

What a great interview this was, the best yet! they asked great questions. I loved when Josh got all worked about when the interviewer asked him about the dirty player who was taking late hits on Aaron. He said he could see Josh getting all worked up. Josh said i don't care if he's got 100 pounds on me! And then when talking about Nick and Josh said he was backstage in seclusion, Andi says something to the affect of , so he didn't bash his skull in.

I think the announcement in a couple of weeks is that they're both doing dancing with the stars. they're not going to announce a wedding date so early, unless they're doing a show leading up to it and that's what they are going to announce. The timing of "a couple of weeks" seems to fit with Sept 4th's DWTS cast announcement.

Interesting post. I guess I have to listen to the interview to really grasp things better. It does put things into perspective though that he hadn't said I love you up to Nick's post. Explains why, out of frustration she just gave into Nick. Had he told her upfront - Nick probably might not have even gotten an option to go into the fantasy suite! Concerning DWTS, who knows, maybe they'd learn some steps for their wedding dance! I guess competing against each other too would also make them want and love each other more - add some more spice (not that they need it) to the relationship.

Its really unfortunate.. the way she over analyzed things! Josh is everything she's ever wanted but she was really just scared to grab it and kept think the whole time "he is to good to be true". I also think producers set her up a little bit. NO WAY she would have sleep with Nick if Josh's date was first and if she knew Josh was completely in love with her. We saw in 1 interview CH said it was tough to convince Andi to "test" what she had with Josh.

Josh said during interview today, it was game over for him after FS.

Anyone think she told Josh she slept with Nick during their FS? I remember their LCD and she asked Josh if he ahd any questions and Josh said, no questions and he is ready and he knows everything about her?

So glad Josh hung in there with her.

[laurentx]

I agree with you bamagal. This is the best love story even with Andi trying to hide her feelings for Josh. Her feelings still came thru with her famous words "Is this too good to be true". Glald to see how much Josh fell in love with her. I wish they would make a DVD of all the JODI scenes.

I agree with what you guys said. The most disappointing part for me was in the DR when Josh said on the bench with Andi that he loves her. It was clear that she had heard him say it before - perhaps on the HTD. And I'm really disappointed that TPTB robbed us of that precious moment, given how enamored she looked when he told her I'm falling in love with you.

After the interview today, I'm convinced he did not say ILY during HTD.   He said today she actually thought he was going to leave.    I guess even after HTD  she was  still scared and convinced herself Josh was going to pull a Brooks on her.

I do agree on the bench was not the first time he said it...she did not look surprised.  So may be he said it earlier during the date.  The moment he saw her (if he couldn't wait to get it off his chest) and  maybe and producers had him tell her again on the bench...just a theory.  

I have been saying this.. I'm positive Andi must have either talked to Des at length before her season started, or the producers, who reminded her what happened to Des because she had invested so much into Brooks at the expense of the others. Even after HTD's, in the back of her mind Andi was afraid that Josh could still leave and she needed to keep moving forward with Nick. It is so apparent from Nick's MTP and on, that she had already detached.

It totally makes sense and I can't blame Andi at all.. so refreshing that Jodi are so candid. Can't wait to hear the interview!

[1funnyfish]

Looks like the radio show uploads interviews every couple of days or so.....anyone want to reach out and request they upload it today?

[Guest]

I agree with what you guys said. The most disappointing part for me was in the DR when Josh said on the bench with Andi that he loves her. It was clear that she had heard him say it before - perhaps on the HTD. And I'm really disappointed that TPTB robbed us of that precious moment, given how enamored she looked when he told her I'm falling in love with you.

After the interview today, I'm convinced he did not say ILY during HTD.   He said today she actually thought he was going to leave.    I guess even after HTD  she was  still scared and convinced herself Josh was going to pull a Brooks on her.

I do agree on the bench was not the first time he said it...she did not look surprised.  So may be he said it earlier during the date.  The moment he saw her (if he couldn't wait to get it off his chest) and  maybe and producers had him tell her again on the bench...just a theory.  

I have been saying this.. I'm positive Andi must have either talked to Des at length before her season started, or the producers, who reminded her what happened to Des because she had invested so much into Brooks at the expense of the others.  Even after HTD's, in the back of her mind Andi was afraid that Josh could still leave and she needed to keep moving forward with Nick.  It is so apparent from Nick's MTP and on, that she had already detached.

It totally makes sense and I can't blame Andi at all.. so refreshing that Jodi are so candid.  Can't wait to hear the interview!

EXACTLY to the bolded!!  I think producers reminded her every chance they got that, don't throw your eggs in the Josh basket.  Remember what happened to Des and Brooks.

[Sponsored content]