Re: Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 9 - Fantasy Dates - July 14/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion - Thread #2

[chloep]

Just read CH blog.  The results of the lie detector test will be read at the MTA.  I hope they leave Josh's out since he is not there and Nick did not take it.  That would only be fair.

I don't mind them revealing the results, especially if it reflects that Josh was actually one of the three deemed to have been truthful.     But it really doesn't matter because they are not always reliable.  I hope that whatever they reveal is really all for laughs and that nothing reflects absolutely terribly for the guys.  We've heard the worst for Dylan already I suspect, for example.

Actually it reflects that Josh was the least truthful of the bunch...    :hidingchair 

2 guys did not lie: Brian, Chris
2 guys lied once: Marcus, Dylan .... (Dylan lied about liking brunettes more than blondes; and Marcus lied about having slept with less than 20 girls)
1 guy lied twice: Josh..... Andi stopped CH from telling what he lied about.

[sdmom]

Why did they even bring this up again? To cast more doubts on Josh and insecurities on Andi? I don't like it  

[Alanna]

Why did they even bring this up again? To cast more doubts on Josh and insecurities on Andi? I don't like it  

I don't think she's insecure any more. I think the original fight was because she was demanding an ily and playing mind games with him, and he had no idea and was just actually angry at the test.

[Di_ATL]

 

Why did they even bring this up again? To cast more doubts on Josh and insecurities on Andi? I don't like it  

I don't think she's insecure any more. I think the original fight was because she was demanding an ily and playing mind games with him, and he had no idea and was just actually angry at the test.

I think alot of her insercurites left, when he told her about the rose scenario on HTD, that the 10th one was for when he was the last guy and got down on 1 knee to propose to HER.
Then also when his MOM confirmed she has NEVER seen JOSH so touch and she grab Andi to display the affection.
Wehn he kept telling her FD night i think her glow before her showhing the card and asking what his thoughts were about going to the Fantasy sweet, she is lost in everything Josh just like she was when she layed back on the couch, on their second 1 0n 1 date.

Her blog states she couldnt wait to spend the night with Josh....very telling to me.     Then aplogizing to MOm and DAD to sweet...she knows it got steamy i bet alot had to be cut out of that scene.....from the pool to the room after drinking his aphrodisiak...hmmmm   

[pander3575]

Considering the lie detector test picks up on your emotions and Josh was irritated he had to take it that could have caused a couple questions to show up as lies. Even Andi had a couple lies and they may not really been either.

I think the show just didn't have enough drama to make a show about so they had to use whatever they could.

[chloep]

^^ *cough* that's why you are asked the questions twice.  :hidingchair 

[pander3575]

and we know they can't be used in court because of it not being reliable.

[Cecilia]

^^ *cough* that's why you are asked the questions twice.  :hidingchair 

Well, it explains why he was so upset.

[docnash14]

Just read CH blog.  The results of the lie detector test will be read at the MTA.  I hope they leave Josh's out since he is not there and Nick did not take it.  That would only be fair.

I don't mind them revealing the results, especially if it reflects that Josh was actually one of the three deemed to have been truthful.     But it really doesn't matter because they are not always reliable.  I hope that whatever they reveal is really all for laughs and that nothing reflects absolutely terribly for the guys.  We've heard the worst for Dylan already I suspect, for example.

Actually it reflects that Josh was the least truthful of the bunch...    :hidingchair 

2 guys did not lie: Brian, Chris
2 guys lied once: Marcus, Dylan .... (Dylan lied about liking brunettes more than blondes; and Marcus lied about having slept with less than 20 girls)
1 guy lied twice: Josh..... Andi stopped CH from telling what he lied about.

JJ was also part of that group date.

[Guest]

I know I'm a party of one, but I kind of love Andi. I think she is legitimately trying to do the best for everyone including herself. I think she's open to all relationships and backing out only when she is confident about her feelings. Chris seemed respectful of her decision and grateful for the timing.

Admittedly, I'm looking through Jodi colored glasses. They're freakin' adorable together. I want it to be two weeks from now already so I can finally let me freak flag fly and lap up all the post-show media and cuteness. Don't let me down!

I like Andi too. She is who she is and aknowledge it. I think she tries hard to "do the job" and that is one issue... it should NOT   feel to us viewers that it is a job.
but i like that she has been opened, and honest (as much as they'll let TB be!)

I agree with both of you. The lead always has a tough balancing act to pull off. I love Sean, and yet at the time there were comments that he should not have led Lindsay so thoroughly. It's just the nature of the bach. Plus, it seems to me that the female leads get more heavily criticized, which is to be expected when the majority of the viewers are female. I like Andi and think she is a good person who has tried hard to do the right thing within the structure of this show. But then, I have liked all the bachelorettes so far.

[Guest]

2 guys did not lie: Brian, Chris
2 guys lied once: Marcus, Dylan .... (Dylan lied about liking brunettes more than blondes; and Marcus lied about having slept with less than 20 girls)
1 guy lied twice: Josh..... Andi stopped CH from telling what he lied about.

JJ is missing and therefore must be the one who lied 3 times.

[Piper61]

Just read CH blog.  The results of the lie detector test will be read at the MTA.  I hope they leave Josh's out since he is not there and Nick did not take it.  That would only be fair.

I don't mind them revealing the results, especially if it reflects that Josh was actually one of the three deemed to have been truthful.     But it really doesn't matter because they are not always reliable.  I hope that whatever they reveal is really all for laughs and that nothing reflects absolutely terribly for the guys.  We've heard the worst for Dylan already I suspect, for example.

Actually it reflects that Josh was the least truthful of the bunch...    :hidingchair:

2 guys did not lie: Brian, Chris
2 guys lied once: Marcus, Dylan .... (Dylan lied about liking brunettes more than blondes; and Marcus lied about having slept with less than 20 girls)
1 guy lied twice: Josh..... Andi stopped CH from telling what he lied about.

    I see that now that I have read what RS posted!  I do think Steel made a good point in Josh's fan thread...with how worked up he was about having to take the test in the first place, etc., she stated she would have been surprised if he had passed without registering a lie.  I agree!  Even having the questions asked more than once.  If your emotions are already at a peak, then having to answer again can also add more anxiety, but with some I am sure it also can have the reverse affect.  I took a lie detector test back when I was extremely young, volunteered to do so for my employer and it was nerve wracking ... luckily they could tell I was extremely nervous and I passed.

[Sponsored content]