Re: Bachelorette 10 - Facebook - Twitter - Updates - Discussion * Sleuthing *Spoilers* Thread #2

[MJC1969]

MJC, the right lower picture in that collage. Where is that from. Josh's IG picture is cut off right at his hat.

Also, I still think the chairs at Hy's place look like a darker frame.

Cut off and lightened to see what was across from him

[pander3575]

I think the dock part looks different also. Hy's picture is wooden, a bit weathered. Josh's almost looks concrete, or even that composite material.

That is what I think.  Josh couldn't take that picture himself....who did?

That is the same question with Josh laying on the bed looking at Sable.  It was also on the 4th, so who took that picture?

It's just strange Andi posting 2 pictures at a lake and Josh posted 1 on the same weekend. Of course they could have been with friends but then why not post with family/friends?

[stuckinsc]

Those type chairs are from big box stores all over the area, so I am not sure that even if they match, which to me they don't if it would matter.

Thank good there is only two weeks left to try to deal with all of this.

And if that is a secluded lake house then Andi isn't ever moving to Iowa.

[soccermom333]

That is what I think.  Josh couldn't take that picture himself....who did?

That is the same question with Josh laying on the bed looking at Sable.  It was also on the 4th, so who took that picture?

It's just strange Andi posting 2 pictures at a lake and Josh posted 1 on the same weekend.  Of course they could have been with friends but then why not post with family/friends?

Exactly! Not to get too technical....... but........ When I look at the two pictures posted by Andi and Josh, I can make an inference, and logically conclude that they are both on a lake and they are probably alone together. There were no pictures of andi or Josh posted with family or friends for that matter. They are both extremely close to their families and if they were not together, would most likely have been with them and posted pictures or would have been mentioned by their prospective families.

#mouthful   

[Piper61]

^^^To answer all, I feel that Andi and Josh were together July 4th, whether it was at one of the family's lake houses, or one rented by TPTB especially for them. The lack of mention of Josh from the Murray family and lack of photos of them with neither friends nor family strongly indicates to me that they were together. Wasn't Nick shown in a picture with his mom at that time?

[pander3575]

Those type chairs are from big box stores all over the area, so I am not sure that even if they match, which to me they don't if it would matter.

Thank good there is only two weeks left to try to deal with all of this.

And if that is a secluded lake house then Andi isn't ever moving to Iowa.

so true. She probably said that because it's so rural getting there. However Chris farm looks like you can't even see another house. I'm not sure city girl would care for it too much but who knows there have been stranger things that happened when you're in love.

[emusha]

I think the dock part looks different also. Hy's picture is wooden, a bit weathered. Josh's almost looks concrete, or even that composite material.

That is what I think.  Josh couldn't take that picture himself....who did?

That is the same question with Josh laying on the bed looking at Sable.  It was also on the 4th, so who took that picture?

which pic is that?

nutty I think the frame can look darker or lighter based on the lighting on it? having a hard time imagining but when you put bright light on something dark or u take a picture with flash does it brighten up or does it get a bit darker

[Alanna]

^^^To answer all, I feel that Andi and Josh were together July 4th, whether it was at one of the family's lake houses, or one rented by TPTB especially for them.  The lack of mention of Josh from the Murray family and lack of photos of them with neither friends nor family strongly indicates to me that they were together.  Wasn't Nick shown in a picture with his mom at that time?

Nick was spotted twice in WI that weekend so he wasn't with Andi either.

I don't think Chris is the f1 so I don't think she was with him.

I guess Hy and company could have been with Andi or her girlfriends and weren't mentioned? I don't know. I personally think she was with Josh because the circumstantial evidence is too much for me to ignore.

[Kashathediva]

That is the same question with Josh laying on the bed looking at Sable.  It was also on the 4th, so who took that picture?

It's just strange Andi posting 2 pictures at a lake and Josh posted 1 on the same weekend.  Of course they could have been with friends but then why not post with family/friends?

Exactly!  Not to get too technical....... but........ When I look at the two pictures posted by Andi and Josh, I can make an inference, and logically conclude that they are both on a lake and they are probably alone together.  There were no pictures of andi or Josh posted with family or friends for that matter.  They are both extremely close to their families and if they were not together, would most likely have been with them and posted pictures or would have been mentioned by their prospective families.  

#mouthful    

I look at all this and say: yes.
Then I look at what MeandI posted and see it was prior to the HTD dates and see her date with Nick occurred at Lakefront Brewery. 
I'm trying to look at all the puzzle pieces.

[Piper61]

^^^To answer all, I feel that Andi and Josh were together July 4th, whether it was at one of the family's lake houses, or one rented by TPTB especially for them.  The lack of mention of Josh from the Murray family and lack of photos of them with neither friends nor family strongly indicates to me that they were together.  Wasn't Nick shown in a picture with his mom at that time?

Nick was spotted twice in WI that weekend so he wasn't with Andi either.

I don't think Chris is the f1 so I don't think she was with him.

I guess Hy and company could have been with Andi or her girlfriends and weren't mentioned? I don't know. I personally think she was with Josh because the circumstantial evidence is too much for me to ignore.

I agree, Alanna. Sometimes things really do just add up circumstantially. Again, why would Josh be wearing a baseball hat down to his eyes at dusk or night while night fishing? I have seen no other pictures of him wearing a hat, not even a visor playing golf.   

[nutty1]

Was that the 4th of July weekend? I think Nick was spotted early on the 4th, and then seen or heard from no more, if my memory serves me correctly. Of course, knowing my memory….   

[Alanna]

Was that the 4th of July weekend? I think Nick was spotted early on the 4th, and then seen or heard from no more, if my memory serves me correctly. Of course, knowing my memory….   

I believe (and sorry if I'm making this up ) that he was spotted early in the weekend and then again in the middle of the weekend by the girl whose sister "laughed in his face."

[Sponsored content]