Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 2 - May 26/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

sophienette wrote:

eusebeia wrote:One thing about Josh being so incoherent--it wasn't likely to have been scripted.

So far I feel everything Andi has said has been scripted.  She's very guarded in a way.  

I think she is very guarded still and analytical. When she talks about the guys, it's all about "I am starting to know them" rather than "i am starting to have feelings for some of them".

But I dont think it has to be a negative. Just how she is.

As fr Josh.. if he can turn that bright red on cue, he deserves an Oscar!

Chemistry wise, I had goosies when they kissed... a slight cringe when Chris and Andy kissed... so there!    

Waiting to see other kisses of course.

Overall, IF Josh is indeed F1, I guess the story is: perfect for each other, but is it too easy? Could someone less "her type" (i.e. Nick) be her type????

That's not even a story.

Did you mean to add something CHO?

atem wrote:

sophienette wrote:

eusebeia wrote:One thing about Josh being so incoherent--it wasn't likely to have been scripted.

So far I feel everything Andi has said has been scripted.  She's very guarded in a way.  

I think she is very guarded still and analytical. When she talks about the guys, it's all about "I am starting to know them" rather than "i am starting to have feelings for some of them".

But I dont think it has to be a negative. Just how she is.

As fr Josh.. if he can turn that bright red on cue, he deserves an Oscar!

Chemistry wise, I had goosies when they kissed... a slight cringe when Chris and Andy kissed... so there!    

Waiting to see other kisses of course.

Overall, IF Josh is indeed F1, I guess the story is: perfect for each other, but is it too easy? Could someone less "her type" (i.e. Nick) be her type????

That's not even a story.  

errr... ok....   maybe I didnt express myself correctly

Where is there any question that it's 'too easy'? There is no story about anything. Just the typical 'someone has a girl friend at home', 'someone drinks too much', 'someone stays on way too long' stuff like always. It's the same thing of MOT guys to dump along the way.

....never mind!

^ I knew what you meant sophienette. In my opinion, it definitely seems like production is really going to show her connections to her F4, which I'm super happy about. It's going to be boiled down to does she pick her type or does she pick the guy she doesn't usually go for?

It's like Josh is her type, which is easy for her because that's what she knows, but Nick isn't necessarily her type, but in the end maybe he really is, but in different ways. I think that's what you were trying to get at! If not - sorry!   

One thing I remember though is Andi from her E! interview said something along the lines of: Yes, I guess I do sort of have a type, but I've learned that while I might like a guy that's always been my type, not every person is the same. Each guy is different and unique and can't really be labeled into a type.

I thought that was a great answer by her.

Ash2214 wrote:^ I knew what you meant sophienette. In my opinion, it definitely seems like production is really going to show her connections to her F4, which I'm super happy about. It's going to be boiled down to does she pick her type or does she pick the guy she doesn't usually go for?

It's like Josh is her type, which is easy for her because that's what she knows, but Nick isn't necessarily her type, but in the end maybe he really is, but in different ways. I think that's what you were trying to get at! If not - sorry!   

One thing I remember though is Andi from her E! interview said something along the lines of: Yes, I guess I do sort of have a type, but I've learned that while I might like a guy that's always been my type, not every person is the same. Each guy is different and unique and can't really be labeled into a type.

I thought that was a great answer by her.

THANKS ASH!!!! You got my point exactly! I was saying the "not her usual type" may be the "obstacle" Andi and Josh have to overcome?

CHO wrote:

sophienette wrote:

eusebeia wrote:One thing about Josh being so incoherent--it wasn't likely to have been scripted.

So far I feel everything Andi has said has been scripted.  She's very guarded in a way.  

I think she is very guarded still and analytical. When she talks about the guys, it's all about "I am starting to know them" rather than "i am starting to have feelings for some of them".

But I dont think it has to be a negative. Just how she is.

As fr Josh.. if he can turn that bright red on cue, he deserves an Oscar!

Chemistry wise, I had goosies when they kissed... a slight cringe when Chris and Andy kissed... so there!    

Waiting to see other kisses of course.

Overall, IF Josh is indeed F1, I guess the story is: perfect for each other, but is it too easy? Could someone less "her type" (i.e. Nick) be her type????

Your quote got split by mistake - ....

I wrote: I agree - I think it is her nature to be guarded/cautious/analytical before she gives in to her feelings.  And I think Nick is that way too - which is good imo.  But maybe they are too much alike - maybe more doubt is generated by Nick's cautiousness - is he trying to convince himself of his feelings?  It does seem odd that Josh is so totally crazy about her - without really knowing her at all.  Maybe we wll more convinced in weeks to come.

To me it's that she has to date a bunch of guys to dump until she gets to be with Josh to determine who's on BIP and who the next Bachelor puppet is.

So is it that Josh - yes he is a jock, drop dead handsome (to her) etc but he is not typical. He can be "her type" but have many redeeming qualities that her past beaux have not had.

No problem sophienette, I'm in agreement with you!


CHO - I think you're right, hence her answer she gave on E! There can be particular types of guys, but no guy is the same. They're all unique.