Re: Catherine & Sean Tweets/Facebook Updates - Thread #21

by **lipsis** Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:32 pm

motheroffive wrote:On the AFtR, Lindsey asked him when he knew it was Catherine and he said at the end of his date with Catherine he knew it was her.

Okay. I thought he meant "our" as in his and Lindsay's. But then Lindsay asked "what is it about that night made him think that" Jeez, my little question has caused more questions than answers.

by motheroffive Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:35 pm

No he meant his date with Catherine because she asked him next what it was about his date with Catherine that made him know. It just tells me hebwas never as conflicted they tried to make us think. They showed her date second for the drama of it,I guess. All those voice overs he did were just to fulfill the storyline!

by blessed66 Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:36 pm

If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

by motheroffive Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:39 pm

blessed66 wrote:If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

I agree with you there. He was just going through the motions to me.

Also they did this with JP's date as well. His date with Ashley was shown second but was actually first.

by **lipsis** Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:46 pm

motheroffive wrote:
blessed66 wrote:If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

I agree with you there. He was just going through the motions to me.

Also they did this with JP's date as well. His date with Ashley was shown second but was actually first.

Oh I agree. I've watched it dozens of times. I always chalked it up to Sean knowing after the fantasy date. I just find it odd that our spoiler here for the order of the dates was wrong. I wanted to ask her a followup question but I didn't want to push my luck since she was already nice enough to reply to me.

by jaspats Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:49 pm

blessed66 wrote:If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

I thought Lindsey had the first LCD becuse he said before his LCD with Catherine that he woke up stressed out because he thougt after his LCD with Lindsey that she could be the one but he hasn't seen Catheine for few days and he misses her already. I understood it as Catherine's LCD wa on his birthday.

by **lipsis** Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:53 pm

jaspats wrote:
blessed66 wrote:If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

I thought Lindsey had the first LCD becuse he said before his LCD with Catherine that he woke up stressed out because he thougt after his LCD with Lindsey that she could be the one but he hasn't seen Catheine for few days and he misses her already. I understood it as Catherine's LCD wa on his birthday.

Not according to Catherine.

by motheroffive Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:56 pm

jaspats wrote:
blessed66 wrote:If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

I thought Lindsey had the first LCD becuse he said before his LCD with Catherine that he woke up stressed out because he thougt after his LCD with Lindsey that she could be the one but he hasn't seen Catheine for few days and he misses her already. I understood it as Catherine's LCD wa on his birthday.

I am embarrassed to say that I have this pretty well memorized - he says he woke out stressed out because he had fallen in love with Lindsey but knew he had fallen in love with Catherine as well. If Catherine's date was first hebdid a voiceover to match their order. And he admitted later he loved Lindsey but was not in love with her.

by jaspats Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:58 pm

lipsis wrote:
jaspats wrote:
blessed66 wrote:If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

I thought Lindsey had the first LCD becuse he said before his LCD with Catherine that he woke up stressed out because he thougt after his LCD with Lindsey that she could be the one but he hasn't seen Catheine for few days and he misses her already. I understood it as Catherine's LCD wa on his birthday.
Not according to Catherine.

Ooops, sorry, lipsis, I just posted without reading your entire discussion. Where is that comment fromCatherine? LOL.

by Macswife8 Fri Aug 23, 2013 8:58 pm

jaspats wrote:
blessed66 wrote:If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

I thought Lindsey had the first LCD becuse he said before his LCD with Catherine that he woke up stressed out because he thougt after his LCD with Lindsey that she could be the one but he hasn't seen Catheine for few days and he misses her already. I understood it as Catherine's LCD wa on his birthday.

I also thought the same and Catherine also mentioned that the big day was tomorrow. Which I always took it to be the night before the proposal. Also always thought that it was for his birthday that she made him the memory book that she did.

Sorry, I also missed the comment from Catherine.

by motheroffive Fri Aug 23, 2013 9:03 pm

I looked back in the archives and the two LCD's were November 15 and November 16. I am not sure until the show came out that we ever knew which was which. Traditionally the first MTP has the first LCD so it would actually make sense that Catherine had the first one.

by motheroffive Fri Aug 23, 2013 9:05 pm

Macswife8 wrote:
jaspats wrote:
blessed66 wrote:If you watch it again you can see during the date with Lindsay, Sean's mind was not present at all.

I thought Lindsey had the first LCD becuse he said before his LCD with Catherine that he woke up stressed out because he thougt after his LCD with Lindsey that she could be the one but he hasn't seen Catheine for few days and he misses her already. I understood it as Catherine's LCD wa on his birthday.
I also thought the same and Catherine also mentioned that the big day was tomorrow. Which I always took it to be the night before the proposal. Also always thought that it was for his birthday that she made him the memory book that she did.

Sorry, I also missed the comment from Catherine.

Lipsis tweeted Catherine and asked if Catherine knew her date was on his birthday and she responded that Lindsey had the date on his birthday.

by Sponsored content