Bachelorette 9 - Screencaps/Photos - Spoilers - Discussion

ImeldaMarcos wrote:

latergator wrote:

auntie wrote:I've been long wondering if it possibly goes with this- or at least where does this fit in?  This is the "other" BSG crying.  Looks like wicker in the background in the top right corner, no?  (P.S. In the close-up that really looks like gold coil now and not beads.)

has anyone noted how clean shaven Brooks neck is in these captures.  I assume everyone is thinking it is Brooks, but Drew has a blue shirt like this too.  could it have been some other time? not even at the end? any help with this would be appreciated.

Actually, I am not sure who it is...but it does resemble Drew's clean hairless self there.

It is definitely Brooks.

Not this again.

atem wrote:Not this again.

ETA : Wanna bet that the question of 'who is on the horse' will come up agian soon ?

latergator wrote:

Bhaka wrote:

ImeldaMarcos wrote:

latergator wrote:

auntie wrote:I've been long wondering if it possibly goes with this- or at least where does this fit in?  This is the "other" BSG crying.  Looks like wicker in the background in the top right corner, no?  (P.S. In the close-up that really looks like gold coil now and not beads.)

has anyone noted how clean shaven Brooks neck is in these captures.  I assume everyone is thinking it is Brooks, but Drew has a blue shirt like this too.  could it have been some other time? not even at the end? any help with this would be appreciated.

Actually, I am not sure who it is...but it does resemble Drew's clean hairless self there.

IMO it also looks more like Drew's thumb.

thank you for that Bhaka... I had thought that, but didn't want to get into the thumbs thing again  
I noticed that Brooks fingers including his thumb are long and lean looking.  this thumb looks more like Drew's to me, more compact.

I have to admit, I thought the thumb looked more like Drew's, too. Brooks' fingers are more slender and long.

Convoluted.

I still wouldn't be surprised if Brooks and Drew have it out with each other at some point.

I apologize if this has already been proven... I am coming from behind.  just an old sleuther from way back.  could someone give me an idea where the conversation regarding this screen capture is?  I'm not convinced it's Brooks or even that it's from the Antigua timeline.

atem wrote:Not this again.

 

I swear between Brooks crying and Des crying SCs, TPTB is having a field day.  They probably login each day to see which picture we are trying to figure out.  I think one day they will throw up their hands and say ..ok..ok. we give up.. here is what happens.  

I thought we recently saw a preview that showed the BSG was Brooks?!? Am I dreaming?

latergator wrote:I apologize if this has already been proven... I am coming from behind.  just an old sleuther from way back.  could someone give me an idea where the conversation regarding this screen capture is?  I'm not convinced it's Brooks or even that it's from the Antigua timeline.

latergator, I came back later in the season as well so I'm still trying to keep all the details straight myself.  But I think this is the long story short on this particular pic...

- before the season even started we had BSG caps- aka Blue Shirt Guy but it was not known who it was
- we now know it's Brooks for several reasons:
(1) we have other caps of Brooks upset in the same clothes;
(2) we have other caps of Brooks opening the mystery door in the same clothes;
(2) we have other caps of Desiree upset in the same clothes and same jewelry;
(3) some very crafty folks here have sleuthed out the backgrounds to figure out the exact location of all of these caps (including the one above) to be the Verandah in Antigua.

Anyway, fingers and shaves aside unless Brooks and Drew/Zak both wore the same outfit on the same day in Antigua and Des is dressed exactly the same in all of them, I think we can safely say they are all Brooks.  I try to keep a health dose of skepticism with all of this but these dots are pretty well connected.

If I've got this wrong, someone please correct me though.

auntie wrote:

latergator wrote:I apologize if this has already been proven... I am coming from behind.  just an old sleuther from way back.  could someone give me an idea where the conversation regarding this screen capture is?  I'm not convinced it's Brooks or even that it's from the Antigua timeline.

latergator, I came back later in the season as well so I'm still trying to keep all the details straight myself.  But I think this is the long story short on this particular pic...

- before the season even started we had BSG caps- aka Blue Shirt Guy but it was not known who it was
- we now know it's Brooks for several reasons:
(1) we have other caps of Brooks upset in the same clothes;
(2) we have other caps of Brooks opening the mystery door in the same clothes;
(2) we have other caps of Desiree upset in the same clothes and same jewelry;
(3) some very crafty folks here have sleuthed out the backgrounds to figure out the exact location of all of these caps (including the one above) to be the Verandah in Antigua.

Anyway, fingers and shaves aside unless Brooks and Drew/Zak both wore the same outfit on the same day in Antigua and Des is dressed exactly the same in all of them, I think we can safely say they are all Brooks.  I try to keep a health dose of skepticism with all of this but these dots are pretty well connected.

If I've got this wrong, someone please correct me though.

Thank you! :Smiley: I am so sorry that I may have missed "some" of that sleuthing and posted a question that aggravated other posters. I was not aware that we had to pass a test before posting. :shocked!: 

auntie wrote:

latergator wrote:I apologize if this has already been proven... I am coming from behind.  just an old sleuther from way back.  could someone give me an idea where the conversation regarding this screen capture is?  I'm not convinced it's Brooks or even that it's from the Antigua timeline.

latergator, I came back later in the season as well so I'm still trying to keep all the details straight myself.  But I think this is the long story short on this particular pic...

- before the season even started we had BSG caps- aka Blue Shirt Guy but it was not known who it was
- we now know it's Brooks for several reasons:
(1) we have other caps of Brooks upset in the same clothes;
(2) we have other caps of Brooks opening the mystery door in the same clothes;
(2) we have other caps of Desiree upset in the same clothes and same jewelry;
(3) some very crafty folks here have sleuthed out the backgrounds to figure out the exact location of all of these caps (including the one above) to be the Verandah in Antigua.

Anyway, fingers and shaves aside unless Brooks and Drew/Zak both wore the same outfit on the same day in Antigua and Des is dressed exactly the same in all of them, I think we can safely say they are all Brooks.  I try to keep a health dose of skepticism with all of this but these dots are pretty well connected.

If I've got this wrong, someone please correct me though.

thanks for the reply auntie, guess I will just have to watch and see.  

I do recall a huge debacle in De's season about who was in the first limo... glad I was part of figuring that one out anyway.  didn't have the spoilers so much back then, just picking captures apart, creating negatives, etc.  

I was also a big part of sleuth for Ali's season.  I could prove to you that based on the "evidence" Chris L was F1 in spite of what the spoilers said.  didn't happen in the end.

this is the first season since then I have been interested enough to start searching again

ImeldaMarcos wrote:
Thank you! :Smiley: I am so sorry that I may have missed "some" of that sleuthing and posted a question that aggravated other posters. I was not aware that we had to pass a test before posting. :shocked!: 

don't forget to pee in that jar and leave a blood sample at the door