Episode 5 - 2/04 - Bachelor 17 - Discussion - Spoilers

Desiree telling Sean he is making a mistake must be when he lets her go at the F4 rose ceremony.

sophienette wrote:Guess that will fuel the "2nd choice F1" fuel, even if just producer created!

Oh you know it will Sophie, but I don't believe it for a moment.

I think the previews show sean was in love with Tierra until she left.

ThankMeLater wrote:I think the previews show sean was in love with Tierra until she left.

But is it the truth, or just more TPTB BS? I guess everyone will choose to believe what they want.

I hate it that they wasted pretty much the whole preview on Tierra drama when she's only around for 2 more episodes. Move on, already, show.

Also, Sean has more success breaking logs when he throws them rather than using an ax. He should keep that in mind.

I think the letter might be from Catherine. She has been giving him notes throughout so far. I wonder if it isn't necessarily a "negative" letter from her but they are playing it off that way in the previews. The VO of "How can she do this to me." during the letter previews was probably something he said another time during the season. I think they are trying to shake things up and make it seem like something it isn't. JMO

ThankMeLater wrote:I think the previews show sean was in love with Tierra until she left.

I think he liked her a lot but in no way do I think he was in love with her. JMO

I must say that normally a contestant (In my mind) is disliked as a lead but in MY case I really like Sean in the lead role even more then in the contestant role. I find myself nodding at the things he says and agreeing with the decisions he makes.

I could tell the story of Tierra losing her BF really tugged at his heartstrings. Now, whether that was amazing timing or not, that must have been heartbreaking for her ... or anyone for that matter.

I felt SO bad for Lesley when Sean only wanted to question her about Tierra .... dude come on!

I like that my girl Lindsay was not involved with any of this bull$hit. Go Yenter!! (but not with Sean because I really don't see "it"... just because I <3 you LOL... don't judge!)

All in all, sad episode... Cat is still in the "you're hot" phase which despite the fact that it worked for Ali and Roberto I found it mildly annoying and the feeling still does not last.

I think Sean's best bets were Lesley (even tho she is politico and that freaks me out a little bit. Sorry political peeps), Dez (who doesn't love dez?!) and sadly Tierra and all of her craziness because let's be honest sometimes the heart wants what it wants.

.... I like Ashlee too but I'm not feeling it with Sean. JMO

I thought I might have saw the bottom of Lindsay's hair as the girl riding the elephant, but I know Catherine also has a light color at the ends of her hair right? So it's one of them.

I also heard a voice over of Catherine (I think) sounding upset....Anyone else heard it?

sophienette wrote:

ThankMeLater wrote:I think the previews show sean was in love with Tierra until she left.

But is it the truth, or just more TPTB BS? I guess everyone will choose to believe what they want.

Ain't it the truth. There are people who still swear to this day that Ashley was in love with Bentley and JP was her fallback choice.

Well TPTB have been doing this for 25 seasons.... they know their job well!