Working eliminations chart and discussions

babymama wrote:

Coastal wrote:

Huh, well it all gives me food for thought then..........maybe I am not so far wrong on the other dates/eliminations.

yeah, you kind of are. you have at least one 1 on 1 date wrong in every episode starting from episode 3. and you have none of the 1 on 1s in Hong Kong right

That's funny............as per RS, Mickey, Ryan, Ames and Blake are on the group date..........kinda narrows the numbers down now don't it?? And according to one of your posts early in the game here, you said that the 2 on 1 happens later in the season and you also hinted that both are sent home on that date...........so in light of everything, that really narrows the numbers down. IMO

Coastal wrote:

That's funny............as per RS, Mickey, Ryan, Ames and Blake are on the group date..........kinda narrows the numbers down now don't it?? And according to one of your posts early in the game here, you said that the 2 on 1 happens later in the season and you also hinted that both are sent home on that date...........so in light of everything, that really narrows the numbers down. IMO

RS only showed photos of two teams on the boat race group date in HK. doesn't mean there wasn't a 3rd team competing

babymama wrote:

Coastal wrote:

That's funny............as per RS, Mickey, Ryan, Ames and Blake are on the group date..........kinda narrows the numbers down now don't it?? And according to one of your posts early in the game here, you said that the 2 on 1 happens later in the season and you also hinted that both are sent home on that date...........so in light of everything, that really narrows the numbers down. IMO

RS only showed photos of two teams on the boat race group date in HK. doesn't mean there wasn't a 3rd team competing

Except for the little fact that he said that there were only 2 teams of 2

babymama wrote:

Hotmomma wrote:
Doesn't Bentley leave in Epi 3 not Epi 2?

yes. one of many things wrong with these charts. i guess i don't understand putting up a chart based on assumptions. what's the point knowing it's gonna have numerous mistakes?

As stated it is a work in progress and a starting point. And the point of the chart is for us to see visually what happens each episode, with RS being so long winded, a chart is much clearer with the info. And as to the point of RS having it all right and that there is no point to slueth further?!? I believe you may want to refer to RS's last two seasons and his F1 choices to clarify why we will continue to slueth and use what we have to confirm RS's info. :giggle:

Coastal wrote:

RS only showed photos of two teams on the boat race group date in HK. doesn't mean there wasn't a 3rd team competing

Except for the little fact that he said that there were only 2 teams of 2[/quote]

i guess he found out otherwise. there was another team competing that he never received a picture of

babymama wrote:

Coastal wrote:

That's funny............as per RS, Mickey, Ryan, Ames and Blake are on the group date..........kinda narrows the numbers down now don't it?? And according to one of your posts early in the game here, you said that the 2 on 1 happens later in the season and you also hinted that both are sent home on that date...........so in light of everything, that really narrows the numbers down. IMO

RS only showed photos of two teams on the boat race group date in HK. doesn't mean there wasn't a 3rd team competing

Babymama, is the date with Will a 1-on-1 in Chang Mai or Phuket? I understand if you cannot answer.

jelle wrote:Thanks for all the work Coastal. I think it is always great to have a concrete starting point. Great sleuthing LoveMe and all!

Makes no sense to me to be critical without offering some solutions or corrections, especially when the issue is that one list is different than RS list.

You all have done a mavelous job with this site. Kudos to those of you who work so hard at running the site, sleuthing clues, and making the board fun.

Thank you so much jelle for your kind words! We really appreciate it!

jelle wrote:Thanks for all the work Coastal. I think it is always great to have a concrete starting point. Great sleuthing LoveMe and all!

Makes no sense to me to be critical without offering some solutions or corrections, especially when the issue is that one list is different than RS list.

You all have done a mavelous job with this site. Kudos to those of you who work so hard at running the site, sleuthing clues, and making the board fun.

Somehow this escaped me in the fray................my bad on that!! Thanks so much for the comments jelle 8)

Coastal wrote:

jelle wrote:Thanks for all the work Coastal. I think it is always great to have a concrete starting point. Great sleuthing LoveMe and all!

Makes no sense to me to be critical without offering some solutions or corrections, especially when the issue is that one list is different than RS list.

You all have done a mavelous job with this site. Kudos to those of you who work so hard at running the site, sleuthing clues, and making the board fun.

Somehow this escaped me in the fray................my bad on that!! Thanks so much for the comments jelle 8)

I missed it too! Thanks Jelle. We're really glad that you're here. :hug:

JMHO. The fun of this and other sleuthing sites is the opportunity to suggest ideas, make assumptions, consider, reconsider, throw everything out and start all over. It stretches the imagination, gets the analytical juices flowing and makes me laugh. I read ideas that never crossed my mind and I learn. I learn about the posters and the way they think. And I laugh. This isn't about perfection or, really, about the final result. That is the icing on the cake. The cake is the process, and I love to bake. I love to see the efforts and yes, the obsession, that some posters have and I cheer them on. I love that people will put themselves out there without caring if they are "wrong" or "wacky". We just like to play along. Is getting to the F1 the ultimate goal? Of Course, but it is so much more fun to be part of the process of trying to figure it out than it is to just read what someone else was told from inside sources. I love the info we get from RS and anyone else, but it doesn't compare to the awesome work done on this site and other sites like it (not as good as ours of course). I just like it here and wouldn't trade my BBF's here for a place at the table of the FRC. Great job to all the wonderful posters who put themselves out there and spend so many hours sifting through millions of pictures, words and threads to get us info. My hat is off to you and I hope you don't ever let naysayers detract from the fun we have "baking" our B'ette season.

Peppermom wrote:JMHO. The fun of this and other sleuthing sites is the opportunity to suggest ideas, make assumptions, consider, reconsider, throw everything out and start all over. It stretches the imagination, gets the analytical juices flowing and makes me laugh. I read ideas that never crossed my mind and I learn. I learn about the posters and the way they think. And I laugh. This isn't about perfection or, really, about the final result. That is the icing on the cake. The cake is the process, and I love to bake. I love to see the efforts and yes, the obsession, that some posters have and I cheer them on. I love that people will put themselves out there without caring if they are "wrong" or "wacky". We just like to play along. Is getting to the F1 the ultimate goal? Of Course, but it is so much more fun to be part of the process of trying to figure it out than it is to just read what someone else was told from inside sources. I love the info we get from RS and anyone else, but it doesn't compare to the awesome work done on this site and other sites like it (not as good as ours of course). I just like it here and wouldn't trade my BBF's here for a place at the table of the FRC. Great job to all the wonderful posters who put themselves out there and spend so many hours sifting through millions of pictures, words and threads to get us info. My hat is off to you and I hope you don't ever let naysayers detract from the fun we have "baking" our B'ette season.

Wonderful Post Peppermom..............Thanks so much!! :loveyou:

nikkij_26 wrote:Ok so it's being said that the F6 we currently have is wrong.

Current F6:

Ben F-HTD per RS
Constantine (Dino)- HTD per RS
Ryan P-Hong Kong pic
Ames-Hong Kong Pic
Mickey-Hong pic
Blake- Hong Kong pic

So, if RS is supposed to be all knowing and correct, then Ben F and Constantine can't be wrong because they came from him. The other 4 came from pics of them in Hong Kong. So, we either have to look back at the Hong Kong pics and see if one of those identified is actually a different guy or the pics we think are in Hong Kong are actually in a different location.

Also we have William and Ben C as being a part of the F8 in Hong Kong. However, I don't see any indication on the chart of how it was verified that William and Ben C were a part of the F8. Was it merely a process of elimination based on who else had been sent home by that time? And if so how reliable was the info? If it wasn't reliable we could have two different guys in the F8. And then those 2 different guys or William and Ben C make it past Hong Kong into the F6 over Ryan P , Ames, Mickey, or Blake. Therefore also changing up 1 or 2 of the F4.

So, how do we know for sure that Ben C & William made it to the F8 in Hong Kong? And how do we know they din't make it to the F6?

reposting this here.