Bachelorette 19 - Gabby Windey - Rachel Recchia - F1-F6 - *Sleuthing Spoilers*

Daily Mail has pictures of what looks like Colton arriving at DWTS. It's in this thread Here

Just a reminder, if we are posting opinions, it must be followed by imo In My Opinion. If it is a fact, a source must be provided to confirm the fact.

This forum does not take anything as fact unless it's proven with a copy and a link as to where the fact came from.

How cute ! T4p.

Definitely looks like it's the same hoodie to me. IMO

Hoodie looks like a match to me IMO

Hoodie looks like a match to me as well. So if this is Gabby (which I believe it is) I feel like she just inadvertently confirmed she picked Erich and they’re still together

I haven’t done much sleuthing this season, but based on my experiences, the lead/F1 will slip up intentionally or non-intentionally, and give us some clues, especially near the end of the season. So we had Kaitlyn’s Snapchat, Bryan’s watch, Tayshia’s ring, and Nayte’s dog Percy. Now it’s Erich’s hoodie!

It's so hard to tell with hoodies, I think, because there are so many of them out there and so many people have them.  The one thing I would say is that in the photos posted above, if you look at Erich's right wrist, the cuff is roomy around his wrist.  If you look at the cuff on Gabby's right wrist, it is more snug around her wrist.  She is very thin and I would think her wrists are narrower than Erich's, so I don't see how his sweatshirt could be as fitted around her wrists, especially when they are a little loose around his.  Also, Jesse described Erich as being 6'4" or 6'5".  I always thought he was tall, but I actually didn't realize he was that tall, I thought e was 6'3".  If he's 6'4", that means he is 7 inches taller than Gabby.  I think on the show, the sweatshirt at least went to his hips if not a little bit lower.  That makes me think that it would fall lower on Gabby's thigh than where it actually falls.  Just overall he is a much taller and broader person than she is, and the sweatshirt doesn't fall that much lower on her arm (looking at the seam) than it does on his.

It's really hard with these things, because as I said above everyone and their brother has these hoodies. Also, at this point people have their favorites so we all tend to see what we want to see and what confirms our hopes.  When I first saw the sweatshirts comparison, I also thought it was a match.  But in studying them a little bit more, I just think they are two standard solid-colored hoodies in different sizes (and I think the color may actually be different too, but that's harder to tell).

All IMO

Can they get in trouble ?

@nd4reality Even if Gabby is wearing Erich’s hoodie (like I explained above, for a number of reasons I don’t think she is), I don’t think she would get in trouble because as I said above hoodies are ubiquitous.  Everybody has them. It’s no KB and Shawn in bed. 

IMO

Honestly, at this point, more signs point to Erich as F1 than Jason. IMO

1) RS spoiler. He's been very careful with his spoilers and only post them when he's absolutely sure now.
2) The edit. Jason was only featured on the show on his dates (1:1 and HT). He was pratically invisible in episodes 2-3-5-6 and only had his limo entrance shown in E1, no conversations. And no conversations or time with Gabby outside their dates.
3) Gabby saying Erich was a rock and that he always came back no matter how she beat him down. I doubt she would she say that about her F2.
4) Erich holding the engagement ring
5) Hoodiegate

The only thing that could point to Jason are the SHVs. But it looks like Gabby took pointers from Susie on how to post later grams.

I don't have a favorite, I would rather Gabby end up with Jason so we could have Erich as bachelor instead of Zach, Greg or Tyler C.

Of course this is only my opinion.

Wonder who is blabbing to RS. I respect the leads and teams that kept a lid on their endings as they ought.

On another note, after the Paris episode I thought it was Tino and Jason as the way they posted about the episode was similar.