Bachelorette 13 - Rachel Lindsay - Episode 10 FRC - Aug 7 - *Sleuthing Spoilers* #3

Rolly wrote:

jalkire wrote:Eric comments are ridiculous to me. Your going to question what you witnessed in person vs and edit tv show. Ok I guess.

Watching the show you have much more data to make a judgement. You see the individual dates, group dates and private time. Edit certainly matters but evidently so does watching the good bye/break up scene.

pbmax wrote:

Rolly wrote:

jalkire wrote:Eric comments are ridiculous to me. Your going to question what you witnessed in person vs and edit tv show. Ok I guess.

Watching the show you have much more data to make a judgement. You see the individual dates, group dates and private time. Edit certainly matters but evidently so does watching the good bye/break up scene.

You will certainly see it in real time, Jason saw it with Graham and commented about it the whole time Graham was there, the ladies saw it with Emily,  you can definitely tell. I still like Eric but I think other things are swaying his comments,  Peter is now his boy.

pbmax wrote:

Cocoasneeze wrote:@FashionLover then why did he try to get to see her again after they did break up? Why did he say that 'We' re not breaking up' if he was offering her out. Imo they both knew they were breaking up, but it was hard, because they both suck at break ups, and want to rehash it to no end. Imo this is yet another reason, why they'd suck as a couple. Their arguments would last for days, because they would rehash and rehash and rehash and talk in circles.  Neither one could just move on. Jmo

It would have been so nice if we could have seen that whole scene in it's entirety and not all chopped up because we would have come to a different conclusion,  but tptp got the reactions they wanted. I had a hard time following along with such chopped edit. After they came back from commercial and Peter and Rachel was sitting quiet,  Peter say we not breaking up, that told me that Rachel had to say it was over but they chose to edit it out and probably edited out a lot of stuff they didn't want us to hear.

FashionLover wrote:

pbmax wrote:

Cocoasneeze wrote:@FashionLover then why did he try to get to see her again after they did break up? Why did he say that 'We' re not breaking up' if he was offering her out. Imo they both knew they were breaking up, but it was hard, because they both suck at break ups, and want to rehash it to no end. Imo this is yet another reason, why they'd suck as a couple. Their arguments would last for days, because they would rehash and rehash and rehash and talk in circles.  Neither one could just move on. Jmo

It would have been so nice if we could have seen that whole scene in it's entirety and not all chopped up because we would have come to a different conclusion,  but tptp got the reactions they wanted. I had a hard time following along with such chopped edit. After they came back from commercial and Peter and Rachel was sitting quiet,  Peter say we not breaking up, that told me that Rachel had to say it was over but they chose to edit it out and probably edited out a lot of stuff they didn't want us to hear.

I think they both knew they were breaking up but they literally didn't want to, from what it appeared as anyway. Hence the 3 hours instead of 30 minutes. There's only so much you can blame on editing.

bleuberry wrote:I didn't even realize that that was a break up or official goodbye .

Nibbles22 wrote:or, how many times did production say 'stop... can we get that ONE more time'!!  

FashionLover wrote:

Nibbles22 wrote:or, how many times did production say 'stop... can we get that ONE more time'!!  

Considering rachel was giving such epic nicholas sparks lines like "I can't say goodbye" I would assume production was too in awe of what goldmine they had in their laps to even bother asking for an ITM from peter

stuckinsc wrote:

FashionLover wrote:

Nibbles22 wrote:or, how many times did production say 'stop... can we get that ONE more time'!!  

Considering rachel was giving such epic nicholas sparks lines like "I can't say goodbye" I would assume production was too in awe of what goldmine they had in their laps to even bother asking for an ITM from peter

Or maybe Peter was spewing more of his "we aren't breaking up lines". Their were two bad breaker ups in that conversation. Or if I want to snark, perhaps Peter pulled out some more of his stilted I love you and will sacrifice for you lines to help bring up more tears and get his bachelor audition a 10 from the judges instead of just a 9.5.

pbmax wrote:

stuckinsc wrote:

FashionLover wrote:

Considering rachel was giving such epic nicholas sparks lines like "I can't say goodbye" I would assume production was too in awe of what goldmine they had in their laps to even bother asking for an ITM from peter

Or maybe Peter was spewing more of his "we aren't breaking up lines". Their were two bad breaker ups in that conversation. Or if I want to snark, perhaps Peter pulled out some more of his stilted I love you and will sacrifice for you lines to help bring up more tears and get his bachelor audition a 10 from the judges instead of just a 9.5.

He was definitely going for a 10. I wonder why they chose not to show that sitting on the floor crying scene, maybe they felt it was over the top