Josh Murray - Amanda Stanton - BIP 3 - Discussion - #2

I saw Amanda liked a fan's post on Josh's insta defending her to someone saying we have "no idea how many men have met her daughters" so not to judge her that she moved in with Josh within weeks. How pathetic imo that she cannot admit her mistake here to prevent doing the same thing in the future, maybe even when the girls start to get older and really will remember the revolving door of daddies. Every young woman makes mistakes with men imo, but to not be able to admit the screwups and try to be better in the future is the real issue.

And Josh tweeted this:
Josh Allan Murray ‏@JoshAllanMurray  4h4 hours ago
I didn't realize it was so cold in the ATL, gonna hafta get some winter clothes now

Way to keep the mystery under wraps, Josh and company I thought everything was fine and nothing was "fake"?

I hope she's not missing him or something. This morning, I noticed she liked multiple pics Josh had posted of them and the kids back from September.

everly wrote:I hope she's not missing him or something. This morning, I noticed she liked multiple pics Josh had posted of them and the kids back from September.

Hopefully, they are just being two mature adults that realized it wasn't meant to be and will have fond memories of the time they shared together.

IMO there's nothing wrong with the girls meeting new people, even guys Amanda might date. Some people think it's good to see the man interacting with the kids from early on, to establish if he gets on with kids at all. But IMO it's a HUGE mistake to move the guy to live with them after knowing him 4-6 weeks. She needs to recognize this and own it.

I'm sorry but mature and adults are not two words I would use to ever describe these two.  Honestly not sure those two words are part of eithers vocabulary.  

JMO

Young kids are honest people and they can see when someone is geniune, and if one of them did not like Josh he saw through him. I wish Amanda had done things different with him, like dating him and not get engage and listen to her kids intuition because one know something was wrong with him.

How many of us would have a person we knew only a few weeks move in with us and our children? (I'm not taking a poll just asking a rhetorical question)
IMO, it does not matter that they spent weeks with each other intimately on an island. In fact, that raises another question--how many of us would even consider intimacy that quickly with someone others have raised red flags?
I agree with @Ladybug82. Mature and adult are not words I could ever associate with either of them. One reminds me of a Bratz doll and the other a frenzied puppy on crack.

Ladybug82 wrote:I'm sorry but mature and adults are not two words I would use to ever describe these two.  Honestly not sure those two words are part of eithers vocabulary.  

JMO

 

TMZ has confirmed the breakup. Said it happened at the Jingle Ball and Josh ditched her there.

As gentlemanly as ever. I would hope if a guy ever ditched a gal anywhere, that would be the end.

LOL! He really ditched her all dramatic at the Jingle Ball? Reminds me of the time he left Andi all high and dry at her friend's wedding. Really mature behavior, right there. Way to not make a public spectacle. Twice.

Glad they didn't try to deny it any longer, hope we don't see either on BIP4.