Josh Murray - Amanda Stanton - BIP 3 - Discussion - #2

I see more love, tenderness and joy in that photo with Jo than in any one with Josh she's ever posted. Sigh.

@Alanna haha ITA her smile is more natural here compared to the forced and so called 'happy' ones on her Insta

I still say good on Amanda if she was the one to break it off and kick his butt to the curb! She's kinda dumb and makes poor life decisions, but don't hate her at all and definitely see redeeming qualities. Josh brought her down. And she deserves some credit if she saw the light and dropped him. Too bad she lost child support money in that lawsuit cause of this farce. But maybe she can team up with Andi's publishers for Its Not Ok Part II and split the difference!

I can't wait for all the shady subtweeting and #blessed hashtags to come! Lol

Does anyone think it's possible that production will have them announce their breakup on the special? It would be a way to give more validity to Nick, doncha think?

@lipsis Oh man there is somerhing wrong with me because I would LOVE that.

Sprite wrote:^^^I actually think her smile is worse. He always has that horribly toothy grin while hers looks so forced....or maybe it is just hard with the botox.

I'm pretty sure that I noticed the Botox just before the Iheart event they went to and it is true that some people that get Botox can't really smile very well. Not 100% sure but believe she also gets Botox in her lips. At least when she was on BIP. It only takes one botched Botox injection to really mess one up. All my opinions.

What I notice are the bags under both of their eyes. This is so sad to me because I always considered Josh to be such a good looking sexy guy but he just doesn't look the same lately. Still very handsome imo but not like he did a couple years ago. I always thought he and his ex made a stunning couple.

I have a different take on Amanda. She is very high maintenance, loves her children, of course, and is not a bad mother imo but not the best mother in the world like some of her fans think of her. I think of her as cunning and manipulative. She actually imo acted trashy on BIP, having sex on TV, being she is a mother and all. I can see her being on one of the Real Housewives of whatever in a few years and fitting right in with the others.

I'm not making excuses for Josh but I don't believe Amanda ever liked Sabel at all and just went through the motions. He absolutely adores her girls and not many men would even consider taking that on. I do believe it takes two, so if there are problems in the relationship I just can't blame it all on Josh. All my opinions.

If there is a sit-down, don't expect him to do a interview w/ CH since he refused with the first break-up. Though I am expecting "happy couple" pictures the day before/night of the interview and then comes the announcement and all their fans are shocked, just like last time. all JMO. Man J needs a new game plan for these break-ups

I think it takes two to tango and it probably was an oil and water kind of thing once real life intervened.
Duh is DUHHHHHH and BOR is BOR. JMOAA

I'll be the outlier and say I think josh is the problem. Amanda has her faults and whatnot but he treated her abhorrently IMO. He's a loser- does the truth need an "IMO" also??  IMO!!

Kashathediva wrote:I think it takes two to tango and it probably was an oil and water kind of thing once real life intervened.
Duh is DUHHHHHH and BOR is BOR. JMOAA

BOR with any woman is like oil and water.

JMO.  

bluwavz wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:I think it takes two to tango and it probably was an oil and water kind of thing once real life intervened.
Duh is DUHHHHHH and BOR is BOR. JMOAA

BOR with any woman is like oil and water.

JMO.  

Agreed. I'm no fan of Amanda, but what I saw of their relationship on BIP and in those infamous Periscopes, I can't for the life of me understand what any sane woman would see in him. The sex must be amazing for his ex(es) to have put up with him as long as they did. JMO. I think it says something that he apparently hasn't had any long-term relationships apart from these quickie engagements. Not for the past 10 years at least.