Josh Murray - Amanda Stanton - BIP 3 - Discussion

Cue the hackers, it's go time!  SM edits, changes and unfollow/follows ahead.  

JMO

It's a conspiracy.

Lol where's the BOR and why isn't he putting a stop to this? She's so out of line right now. Why is she getting to decide how to do her own life????

He's at home with the kids

^^ It's his choice. Che sera sera. JMHO.

Glad he told us where he was last night. Thanks, Josh!! I love how every time we have a question, they always, always provide us an answer. The best and quickest service I've even seen!! Modern day Ask Jeeves.

Guys, if you have the "answers" to the next big lottery, please share the winning #s with your favorite hatah hatah blog too.

I kind of wish they had a show instead of Ben/Lauren. It would be like "Newlyweds Part 2" (for anyone that doesn't remember, it was a reality show where Jessica Simpson and Nick Lachey were really really dumb).

We might see them on a show in the future, just not their own! IMO.

My 16 yr old daughter and her boyfriend have a more mature relationship than these two.

And, if my child would have said "what the hell" at that age, I would've been too busy washing her mouth out with soap to post the snap.

Well, that's the good thing about this board, we have threads for everyone.  Fan threads for those that only like to read only positive posts and love on the individual or couple.  And general discussion threads that allow for all thoughts and opinions, as long as we respect each other here on the board and their posts, all is good.  We don't have to agree, we just have to agree to disagree.

I don't root against anyone on this show or in life.  I wish them all well and hope for the best for each.  But that doesn't mean I have to believe everything they post.  I do hope there is some truth to some of what they post.  But given we've seen some of this same behavior when he was with Andi, for me personally it makes it a little harder to believe anything they're putting out or trying to project as the perfect, loving, happy couple/family.  I do hope no matter what happens, whether they stay together or not, they make some good memories to look back on years from now and see how it helped shape and form them.  I just have a feeling it'll all eventually go up in flames and the messy break up with Andi will look tame in comparison to what Amanda, her mom, ex, etc. will dish out.  But that's JMOAA

Ladybug82 wrote:Well, that's the good thing about this board, we have threads for everyone.  Fan threads for those that only like to read only positive posts and love on the individual or couple.  And general discussion threads that allow for all thoughts and opinions, as long as we respect each other here on the board and their posts, all is good.  We don't have to agree, we just have to agree to disagree.

I don't root against anyone on this show or in life.  I wish them all well and hope for the best for each.  But that doesn't mean I have to believe everything they post.  I do hope there is some truth to some of what they post.  But given we've seen some of this same behavior when he was with Andi, for me personally it makes it a little harder to believe anything they're putting out or trying to project as the perfect, loving, happy couple/family.  I do hope no matter what happens, whether they stay together or not, they make some good memories to look back on years from now and see how it helped shape and form them.  I just have a feeling it'll all eventually go up in flames and the messy break up with Andi will look tame in comparison to what Amanda, her mom, ex, etc. will dish out.  But that's JMOAA

ITA. Andi Book Gate will look so reasonable, normal and sane once this goes down the tubes imo. He's really between a rock and a hard place here when the last breakup comes, I think. He seems to genuinely love the girls and there's the outside image to protect too. Yikes.

Andi said in her book that Josh helped her not to care so much about what people say about her which leads me to believe that he doesn't live his life caring about what others think or protecting any image IMO. I believe he went into his relationship with Andi hoping to get married and have kids. IMO, that is not what she wanted. I think Amanda is a better fit.