Josh Murray - BIP - Famously Single - Season 3 - *Sleuthing - Spoilers* #2

Well, I'll say it. Yes I think it's gross. And I don't believe for a second that they thought they were off camera. Hoped? Maybe. Drunk? Probably.

I bet if Josh were home watching some other guys do that, he'd have some judgy/snarky tweet at the ready. Basically it's his high sense of self that makes this extra rich, like, dude, you are all one in the same.

If he owned his actions and hopped off his high horse, then yeah, do you.

Why do I feel like we just got jinxed?

GuardianAngel wrote:So it's ok to bang two three people in the FS, who you aren't going to get engaged to, but not in the boom boom room? Serious question.

Camera's or not, it happens, TPTB will make sure every one knows, whether it's in the FS or on BIP.

IA with @Kashathediva. Do whatever you want, I don't want to see it.

Bingo! I was thinking the same thing! At least JAM aren't getting it on with multiple people days before getting engaged to each other. They are all having sex on BIP, Bachelor & Bachelorette whether ptb air the action or not.

I do wonder if they will air the clip on the actual show. Seems to me the promo was trying to portray Amanda/Nick as the couple and most who saw it (that aren't online or spoiled) probably think the guy was Nick; not knowing that Josh is even going to be on BIP so that when Josh turns up and "steals" Nick's latest love, Twitter will explode.

GuardianAngel wrote:So it's ok to bang two three people in the FS, who you aren't going to get engaged to, but not in the boom boom room? Serious question.

Camera's or not, it happens, TPTB will make sure every one knows, whether it's in the FS or on BIP.

IA with @Kashathediva. Do whatever you want, I don't want to see it.

Personally I don't care who does what, when, where with whom and why; however, when it's Josh who called his fiancée all sorts of names for this and Amanda who subtly/not so subtly (imo) tries to show her over the top borderline virginity (ignore 2 kids in your imagination), then yeah, it's different. Jmo.

Fantasy Suite sex won't be watched/listened in on by editing, crew, and potentially millions, so that's something.  

Alanna wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:So it's ok to bang two three people in the FS, who you aren't going to get engaged to, but not in the boom boom room? Serious question.

Camera's or not, it happens, TPTB will make sure every one knows, whether it's in the FS or on BIP.

IA with @Kashathediva. Do whatever you want, I don't want to see it.

Personally I don't care who does what, when, where with whom and why; however, when it's Josh who called his fiancée all sorts of names for this and Amanda who subtly/not so subtly (imo) tries to show her over the top borderline virginity (ignore 2 kids in your imagination), then yeah, it's different. Jmo.

^^Josh's fiancé had sex with Nick days before she got engaged to him and lied to his face about it. Apples/Oranges IMO.

I don't remember Amanda ever trying to portray herself as virginal. All she's portrayed herself as is a single mom.

Josh's name calling IMO had to do more with lying.

It's comical that #26 is once again shafted by #25. It's like a race for the same girl, again. :Bubba:

'At least he's not doing x/y/z'... look, I can think what Andi did was gross/dumb/whatever and what Josh and Amanda did was too. Imagine that .

IG

17h
joshmurray11 Always

GuardianAngel wrote:Josh's name calling IMO had to do more with lying.

It's comical that #26 is once again shafted by #25. It's like a race for the same girl, again. :Bubba:

I know many who don't care for Nick love the idea of another pseudo-triangle with him and Josh where Josh "wins" again but everything I've heard about this season suggests to me that Nick and Amanda went on one date, just like he did with Leah, it was nice, then Josh showed up, she hooked up with Josh and they became a thing. And pretty much at the same time Jennifer showed up and she and Nick became a thing.

I highly doubt Nick was that swept up in Amanda after one date or was pining for her and Josh swooped in and took the girl from him. But again, I guess it makes for more fun for people to make it more than it is and play it up that way. And I'm sure the show and the editing will hint at that but when even RS who hates Nick as much as many here, is making the situation out to be nothing, I'd say it was nothing. Of course silly me in not buying the supposed Josh and Amanda love story and thinking anyone "won" anything here. But then again, I don't get engaged to people after barely knowing them for two weeks, so what do I know.

Blueberry,

That was exactly my thought.  How many of the crew members actually saw this and not what we were shown but the whole deed.   There should be some kind of recourse for Josh and Amanda.  I would think TPTB would have taken into consideration that Amanda is a mother with two little girls.  Doesn't that even go through TPTB's minds when making these decisions on what to cut out and what to show.  Whether they got engaged or not this won't show her in the best light.  And even if this was only shown in the preview and isn't actually aired in an episode just the fact that other people actually saw the whole deed, which should have been private is not a good thing. JMO

For Amanda and Josh's sake I wish this had not been shown on TV.  And, selfishly, as a fan I would rather have not seen this.

lleyki wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:Josh's name calling IMO had to do more with lying.

It's comical that #26 is once again shafted by #25. It's like a race for the same girl, again. :Bubba:

I know many who don't care for Nick love the idea of another pseudo-triangle with him and Josh where Josh "wins" again but everything I've heard about this season suggests to me that Nick and Amanda went on one date, just like he did with Leah, it was nice, then Josh showed up, she hooked up with Josh and they became a thing. And pretty much at the same time Jennifer showed up and she and Nick became a thing.

I highly doubt Nick was that swept up in Amanda after one date or was pining for her and Josh swooped in and took the girl from him. But again, I guess it makes for more fun for people to make it more than it is and play it up that way. And I'm sure the show and the editing will hint at that but when even RS who hates Nick as much as many here, is making the situation out to be nothing, I'd say it was nothing. Of course silly me in not buying the supposed Josh and Amanda love story and thinking anyone "won" anything here. But then again, I don't get engaged to people after barely knowing them for two weeks, so what do I know.

It's all scripted, and nothing more IMO. I should have added a sarcasm smilie. The thought of those two on BIP at the same time must have made them jump for joy. There had to be someone that Nick was interested in that Josh wanted as well. What fun would it be for the viewers if they didn't butt heads IMHO.