Re: Episode 8 - 7/18 Hometown dates - Discussion - Spoilers

by ironcat Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:03 pm

2observe wrote:
ironcat wrote:
2observe wrote:
ironcat wrote:So do we really think that the producers, knowing at this point who the lead is going to pick, set the guys up in a specific order every season so that the sleuthers, right before the last 2 episodes, have the definitive clue to the ending? If they are going to give it away at this point every season, why do they work so hard to make sure the cat doesn't get out of the bag earlier? Or is this just a cool game they play with us, so that we'll know, while taking pains to throw everyone else off the track? Awesome.
Because not many will believe it. I say that the proof is in the pudding. Just look at Jill, Ali' & Ashley's F3 Toasts.

Just curious, why do you think the producers do this? IOW, what would be their motivation for puposely giving out this extremely revealing and easy to interpret clue, that gives away the ending? They certainly don't have to, so why do you suppose they do it? I'd really love an answer from anybody who thinks the toast lineup is so significant and foolproof. Thanks!
Imo, it's just part of production. I really don't think that they think anyone would figure it out.

Pretty sloppy of them then, and I guess we're smarter than they think, huh? But I still don't see the point of it from their side. Why the need to line the guys up in that specific order each season? I understand doing it by height, color of clothes, something logical that has some production value to the finished product. I am at a loss what the elimination order has to do with enhancing production value, if, as you say, it's not meant as a deliberate clue to us. :greenman:

by CHO Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:07 pm

But we never know which of the clues/hints/patterns will be significant. Fleiss is no dummy.

by ironcat Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:19 pm

CHO wrote:But we never know which of the clues/hints/patterns will be significant. Fleiss is no dummy.

Well, I guess the question is, is this a deliberate clue, a pattern that has some significance to production, or just a random coincidence that happened the last two seasons? Since I can't come up with any remotely logical explanation for why the producers would do the first two, I'm going with the third option.

by Samantharose Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:22 pm

mnmhughes wrote:If JP went from F3 to F1, that must have been one HECK of a FD! :what:

by GrahamGal Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:30 pm

Samantharose wrote:
mnmhughes wrote:If JP went from F3 to F1, that must have been one HECK of a FD! :what:

From the looks of the preview it seem to go better than originally advertised. :girlfan

by Alanna Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:31 pm

Samantharose wrote:
mnmhughes wrote:If JP went from F3 to F1, that must have been one HECK of a FD! :what:

LMAO. Well Ashley does say sex is key to a relationship so she must have quickly shuffled around her order in 5 days to make her F3 the F1. I can't lie, I'm nervous that at the end of the week, the spec will be that JP was supposed to be F15 but accidentally slipped through the cracks somehow.

by Reidiscool Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:33 pm

Samantharose wrote:
mnmhughes wrote:If JP went from F3 to F1, that must have been one HECK of a FD! :what:

LOL...but just had another spooky thought....F3 takes himself out just like Ali's season !!!! Ash is seen crying on the couch!!!

by mnmhughes Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:35 pm

Reidiscool wrote:
Samantharose wrote:
mnmhughes wrote:If JP went from F3 to F1, that must have been one HECK of a FD! :what:

LOL...but just had another spooky thought....F3 takes himself out just like Ali's season !!!! Ash is seen crying on the couch!!!

Yep, Dino is out just like Frank.
Another similarity.

by mnmhughes Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:35 pm

Alanna wrote:
Samantharose wrote:
mnmhughes wrote:If JP went from F3 to F1, that must have been one HECK of a FD! :what:

LMAO. Well Ashley does say sex is key to a relationship so she must have quickly shuffled around her order in 5 days to make her F3 the F1. I can't lie, I'm nervous that at the end of the week, the spec will be that JP was supposed to be F15 but accidentally slipped through the cracks somehow.

No kidding! handwave

by chicagoowl Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:40 pm

Alanna wrote:
Samantharose wrote:
mnmhughes wrote:If JP went from F3 to F1, that must have been one HECK of a FD! :what:

LMAO. Well Ashley does say sex is key to a relationship so she must have quickly shuffled around her order in 5 days to make her F3 the F1. I can't lie, I'm nervous that at the end of the week, the spec will be that JP was supposed to be F15 but accidentally slipped through the cracks somehow.

No.. actually if Tim didn't get drunk the first night, JP would have been the first one cut. Thank God for Drunk Tim wine

.... JP jumped from F25 to F3 ...now he just may make it to F1. Woo hoo! :27:

by Alanna Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:44 pm

chicagoowl wrote:
Alanna wrote:
Samantharose wrote:
mnmhughes wrote:If JP went from F3 to F1, that must have been one HECK of a FD! :what:

LMAO. Well Ashley does say sex is key to a relationship so she must have quickly shuffled around her order in 5 days to make her F3 the F1. I can't lie, I'm nervous that at the end of the week, the spec will be that JP was supposed to be F15 but accidentally slipped through the cracks somehow.

No.. actually if Tim didn't get drunk the first night, JP would have been the first one cut. Thank God for Drunk Tim .... JP jumped from F25 to F3 ...now he just may make it to F1. Woo hoo! :27:

Stop!!! I'm on the train and laughing so much, I'm legit getting looks. So freaking funny!! You're right though, Ashley would have had JP escorted out instead, but WOW, it was his lucky day!!

by CHO Sat Jul 23, 2011 7:44 pm

I just want to say that these are the kind of comments that people are talking about. Just keep an open mind - be respectful of others' points of view. Sarcasm imo doesn't really have a place here unless someone is being unreasonable. I don't think that the person who noticed a pattern in the rc line up is joking around. The pattern was noticed - maybe it will be significant - maybe it won't. But no one is stupid here - and you have your opinions and others have theirs.

by Sponsored content