Re: The Bachelor: Women Tell All - 3/04 - Discussion Thread

by jcrbil Mon Mar 04, 2013 11:58 pm

Barbarossa wrote:Allow me to share a thought from a mans perspective:

The only reason a man would have lied to a woman in the fantasy suite scenario is to get sexual favors.

Everyone knows Sean is celibate. It's strongly suggested he is celibate with his fiancée. So why would Sean lie to AshLee?

Answer: he wouldn't. That was one of the most vindictive things I've ever seen.

What I found remarkable is that AshLee challenged Tierra about questioning her integrity (which the editors were very careful to keep in the show).... and then she did the same to Sean.....

It is clear from the comments made that she still feels like the woman scorned- and she had built HUGE expectations about him- ones that he would never in a million years lived up to- because even a saint would not be able to rise to the standard she was expecting. If she felt he was like a frat boy around all the other women, but not with her, she should have come to the conclusion that he had not been himself (at least not 100% himself with her) and instead of recriminations she should know that they were not right for each other. When in public, it is ALWAYS better to take the high road.

by terabithia Mon Mar 04, 2013 11:58 pm

Barbarossa wrote:Allow me to share a thought from a mans perspective:

The only reason a man would have lied to a woman in the fantasy suite scenario is to get sexual favors.

Everyone knows Sean is celibate. It's strongly suggested he is celibate with his fiancée. So why would Sean lie to AshLee?

Answer: he wouldn't. That was one of the most vindictive things I've ever seen.

I'm not sure if she made it up out of revenge or if he said something that she interpreted incorrectly. I do not believe he actually said those words (something about not having any feelings for the other two women) but he may have said something else that she heard completely wrong. So they both believe they are right.

by umngirl Mon Mar 04, 2013 11:58 pm

So did I miss anything of interest in the previews? Those are what I really want to see. Or was it just more of the same?

by riddlexo3 Mon Mar 04, 2013 11:59 pm

I would love for Catherine and Sean to make it as a couple. Just because everyone seems to think they won't .

by Guest Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:00 am

terabithia wrote:
Barbarossa wrote:Allow me to share a thought from a mans perspective:

The only reason a man would have lied to a woman in the fantasy suite scenario is to get sexual favors.

Everyone knows Sean is celibate. It's strongly suggested he is celibate with his fiancée. So why would Sean lie to AshLee?

Answer: he wouldn't. That was one of the most vindictive things I've ever seen.

I'm not sure if she made it up out of revenge or if he said something that she interpreted incorrectly. I do not believe he actually said those words (something about not having any feelings for the other two women) but he may have said something else that she heard completely wrong. So they both believe they are right.

Correct.

by Guest Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:00 am

Yes, what she heard was not what he meant. Their communication wasn't so great. But she was obsessed, and it colored everything she heard.

by deeliciouz Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:02 am

riddlexo3 wrote:I would love for Catherine and Sean to make it as a couple. Just because everyone seems to think they won't .

co-sign.

by 2observe Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:03 am

Barbarossa wrote:Allow me to share a thought from a mans perspective:

The only reason a man would have lied to a woman in the fantasy suite scenario is to get sexual favors.

Everyone knows Sean is celibate. It's strongly suggested he is celibate with his fiancée. So why would Sean lie to AshLee?

Answer: he wouldn't. That was one of the most vindictive things I've ever seen.

Something is not quite clear to me about Sean's celibacy. Was Sean celibate with his last gf???

by Laurabadora14 Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:05 am

deeliciouz wrote:
riddlexo3 wrote:I would love for Catherine and Sean to make it as a couple. Just because everyone seems to think they won't .

co-sign.

Me three! I think they are absolutely adorable!

by Guest Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:05 am

Who knows? But its not important if he was or wasn't. Spiritual conviction can happen any time.

by Kwpn12 Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:05 am

2observe wrote:
Barbarossa wrote:Allow me to share a thought from a mans perspective:

The only reason a man would have lied to a woman in the fantasy suite scenario is to get sexual favors.

Everyone knows Sean is celibate. It's strongly suggested he is celibate with his fiancée. So why would Sean lie to AshLee?

Answer: he wouldn't. That was one of the most vindictive things I've ever seen.

Something is not quite clear to me about Sean's celibacy. Was Sean celibate with his last gf???

I heard that he was. That they were together for two years with no sex. Hmmm ...

by umngirl Tue Mar 05, 2013 12:06 am

2observe wrote:
Barbarossa wrote:Allow me to share a thought from a mans perspective:

The only reason a man would have lied to a woman in the fantasy suite scenario is to get sexual favors.

Everyone knows Sean is celibate. It's strongly suggested he is celibate with his fiancée. So why would Sean lie to AshLee?

Answer: he wouldn't. That was one of the most vindictive things I've ever seen.

Something is not quite clear to me about Sean's celibacy. Was Sean celibate with his last gf???

From what I've gathered, Sean has been celibate for a few years so I would say yes.

by Sponsored content