American Idol 12- Episode Discussions- * Spoilers*

I agree about Nikki. I basically just watch the clips. I am not going to waste my time listening to the judges. Not worth it!

I like Nicki at times, Keith all of the time, Randi & Mariah never.

I'm with you on thinking Kree, Angie, & Candice should be in the f3, Lost17. I thought there are a couple of others who were pretty good last night but I hope Lazaro goes home.

albean99 wrote:I like Nicki at times, Keith all of the time, Randi & Mariah never.

I'm with you on thinking Kree, Angie, & Candice should be in the f3, Lost17. I thought there are a couple of others who were pretty good last night but I hope Lazaro goes home.

I was hoping, but that didn't happen! I didn't watch tonight, just read the spoilers. It's coming to the point I might just watch the vids online of the three I like and skip it on tv.

Another theme I'm not interested in "Motown".

I'm really suspicious why they didn't say who were in the 'top 3' like last time? If Lozaro was in the top 3, then the judges need to learn to not make those boys cry! Never met a group of wimpier guys! Geez!

atem wrote:I'm really suspicious why they didn't say who were in the 'top 3' like last time? If Lozaro was in the top 3, then the judges need to learn to not make those boys cry! Never met a group of wimpier guys! Geez!

It's unusual for them to say who's in the top 3. Even when they say it's the b3 you have to listen carefully to what Ryan says. Sometimes they seem to throw someone in there who really wasn't.

albean99 wrote:

atem wrote:I'm really suspicious why they didn't say who were in the 'top 3' like last time? If Lozaro was in the top 3, then the judges need to learn to not make those boys cry! Never met a group of wimpier guys! Geez!

It's unusual for them to say who's in the top 3. Even when they say it's the b3 you have to listen carefully to what Ryan says. Sometimes they seem to throw someone in there who really wasn't.

The show did it last week with saying who was in the top 3.

I agree with most of you, Lazo should have gone home! I feel Paul's exit was sooner than I thought he would. I like Devin but he'd probably go home next (

Allow me please! #TooBiased

Reviews on Top 9 Beatles' Performance

RT @FoolsApril64: [BLIPS] David Cook mentions in various Idol recaps - EW http://t.co/75UvhtLcNB THR http://t.co/Eh5P136NHO Yahoo!Music http://t.co/2lCbV3RfVy

RT @FoolsApril64: #flashback David Cook - Eleanor Rigby (American Idol S7 - 2008) http://t.co/HqHK3LJpdA

atem wrote:

albean99 wrote:

atem wrote:I'm really suspicious why they didn't say who were in the 'top 3' like last time? If Lozaro was in the top 3, then the judges need to learn to not make those boys cry! Never met a group of wimpier guys! Geez!

It's unusual for them to say who's in the top 3. Even when they say it's the b3 you have to listen carefully to what Ryan says. Sometimes they seem to throw someone in there who really wasn't.

The show did it last week with saying who was in the top 3.

Isn't that the first time they ever did it? Plus they ranked the others as well that night...so yes, unusual they did it in the first place. Not sure what they were trying to accomplish, maybe it's the first time that many girls have ever been in the lead at one time?

Cari I like Devin's voice, he just needs to sing something that showcases it better. :Smiley:

It seems like they are doing what The X Factor does now. Don't they announce who the Top 3 Contestants are during the results show each week?

Love_Me wrote:It seems like they are doing what The X Factor does now. Don't they announce who the Top 3 Contestants are during the results show each week?

X Factor did that, but AI did it one week and didn't the next. Doesn't make sense to me.

Doesn't look like Lazaro will be leaving any time soon...although he is getting worse and worse each week...votes are coming his way from Vote for the Worst!

Tammi wrote:Doesn't look like Lazaro will be leaving any time soon...although he is getting worse and worse each week...votes are coming his way from Vote for the Worst!

I thought they were closing down?