American Idol 12- Episode Discussions- * Spoilers*

atem wrote:I think the main reason I don't 'connect' with this season is due to the judges. I just don't get that they are providing anything of value.

I agree. I fast forward through them, I'd say 4 is way too many, but there are 4 on The Voice and they don't bother me...but I agree you can only hear yo dawg, you were amazing, that was dreadful so many times. And that show has more commercials than any other, if I didn't have DVR I wouldn't watch the show at all.

Yes!

If only we had a few singers on AI like Jon Bon Jovi or Richie Sambora!!! That was so good! Loved Phillip too.

Wasn't surprised by the top 3, but was surprised they said who placed where! If only they'd done that in other seasons. Curtis is an amazing singer, but he was over dramatic when he sang and it was so distracting.

Charlie or Aubrey? I'd pick Aubrey (although it'd be more of the same with that group) but I like her more than Charlie. At least he just sat and sang and didn't do anything crazy, but that's what this tour just might need. lol

Lost17 wrote:If only we had a few singers on AI like Jon Bon Jovi or Richie Sambora!!! That was so good! Loved Phillip too.

Wasn't surprised by the top 3, but was surprised they said who placed where! If only they'd done that in other seasons. Curtis is an amazing singer, but he was over dramatic when he sang and it was so distracting.

Charlie or Aubrey? I'd pick Aubrey (although it'd be more of the same with that group) but I like her more than Charlie. At least he just sat and sang and didn't do anything crazy, but that's what this tour just might need. lol

I say Aubrey, because Charlie can't handle stress.

I love Charlie's voice. Just love it!

HowSoonIsNow wrote:I love Charlie's voice. Just love it!

You think he could handle the responsibility of being on the tour? I don't.

atem wrote:

HowSoonIsNow wrote:I love Charlie's voice. Just love it!

You think he could handle the responsibility of being on the tour? I don't.

He'd probably do ok, singing only a few songs, unlike being on AI with all that pressure...who knows for sure.

Lost17 wrote:

atem wrote:

HowSoonIsNow wrote:I love Charlie's voice. Just love it!

You think he could handle the responsibility of being on the tour? I don't.

He'd probably do ok, singing only a few songs, unlike being on AI with all that pressure...who knows for sure.

Is Charlie still a minor? If so, he'll have a parent along for the tour. Even if he isn't, he might still be able to take a stabilizing force (parent or friend) along. Hopefully his parents are clued in to whether he can handle this or not.

@Lost17 - I flove Sawyer. That is all.

atem wrote:

HowSoonIsNow wrote:I love Charlie's voice. Just love it!

You think he could handle the responsibility of being on the tour? I don't.

Atem, do you mind telling me why you feel this way? I must have missed something..

HowSoonIsNow wrote:Is Charlie still a minor? If so, he'll have a parent along for the tour. Even if he isn't, he might still be able to take a stabilizing force (parent or friend) along. Hopefully his parents are clued in to whether he can handle this or not.

@Lost17 - I flove Sawyer. That is all.

17 or 18 I think.

LoveDovez wrote:

atem wrote:

HowSoonIsNow wrote:I love Charlie's voice. Just love it!

You think he could handle the responsibility of being on the tour? I don't.

Atem, do you mind telling me why you feel this way? I must have missed something..

He had a mental breadown on the show.

Anyone know what the next theme is?